Loading...
02-07-2022 Agenda Packet BOCPERSON COUNTY BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS MEETING AGENDA 304 South Morgan Street, Room 215 Roxboro, NC 27573-5245 336-597-1720 Fax 336-599-1609 February 7, 2022 7:00pm This meeting will convene in the County Office Building Auditorium. CALL TO ORDER………………………………………………….. Chairman Powell INVOCATION PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE DISCUSSION/ADJUSTMENT/APPROVAL OF AGENDA PUBLIC HEARING: Quasi-Judicial Zoning Decision: The special use permit requires a quasi-judicial public hearing. Witnesses are to be sworn in and they are subject to cross-examination. There shall be no ex parte communication without full disclosure at the hearing. ITEM #1 (pgs. 4-36) Petition SUP-05-21 - A request by the applicant, Parallel Infrastructure, LLC (Kelly Young) on behalf of the property owner, Estate of Lonnie Luxton and Carol Luxton, to construct a new 305’ tall self-supported wireless communications tower on 69 acres located at 700 Pixley Pritchard Rd. (Tax Map and Parcel number A84-14) in the RC (Rural Conservation) and B2 (Neighborhood Shopping) Zoning Districts ………………………. Lori Oakley 1 ITEM #2 (pgs. 37-43) Consideration to Grant or Deny Request by the applicant, Parallel Infrastructure, LLC (Kelly Young) on behalf of the property owner, Estate of Lonnie Luxton and Carol Luxton, to construct a new 305’ tall self-supported wireless communications tower on 69 acres located at 700 Pixley Pritchard Rd. (Tax Map and Parcel number A84-14) in the RC (Rural Conservation) and B2 (Neighborhood Shopping) Zoning Districts ……………………………………………………………….. Chairman Powell The Board will need to address the Findings of Fact in Section 155 of the Person County Planning Ordinance and whether this proposal is in keeping with the Person County Land Use Plan. The Findings of Fact in Section 155-3 (b) are as follows: 1.That the use will not materially endanger the public health or safety if located where proposed and developed according to the plan as submitted and approved. 2.That the use meets all required conditions and specifications. 3.That the use will not substantially injure the value of adjoining or abutting property, or that the use is a public necessity, and 4.That the location and character of the use if developed according to the plan as submitted and approved will be in harmony with the area in which it is to be located and in general conformity with the comprehensive plan. INFORMAL COMMENTS The Person County Board of Commissioners established a 10-minute segment which is open for informal comments and/or questions from citizens of this county on issues, other than those issues for which a public hearing has been scheduled. The time will be divided equally among those wishing to comment. It is requested that any person who wishes to address the Board, register with the Clerk to the Board prior to the meeting. ITEM #3 DI SCUSSION/ADJUSTMENT/APPROVAL OF CONSENT AGENDA A.Approval of Minutes of January 18, 2022 (pgs. 44-79),B.Budget Amendment #12 (pg. 80),C.Health Department proposed new fee associated with COVID-19 vaccinations for the administration of the Pfizer pediatric third dose (pgs. 81-82),D.Consultancy Agreement for Professional Services with Economic Leadership, LLC (pgs. 83-88),E.Tax Collector’s Report of Unpaid 2021 Taxes (pg. 89),F.Tax Office requests Order to Set Advertisement of Unpaid Real Estate Taxes to March 3, 2022 (pg. 90),G.Tax Adjustments for February 2022 (pgs. 91-106),a.Tax Releasesb.NC Vehicle Tax System pending refundsH.Fee Schedule Amendment for Transportation to reinstate ROAP mileage rate (pg. 107) 2 OLD BUSINESS: ITEM #4 (pgs. 108-160) Consideration to grant or deny request to revise the Person County Solar Energy System Ordinance (Petition TA-03-21) and a Proposed Zoning Permit Fee and an Annual Inspection Fee …………………Chairman Powell Statement of Reasonableness and Consistency: The text amendment request is consistent with the Person County and City of Roxboro Joint Comprehensive Land Use Plan and future planning goals and objectives of Person County. It is reasonable and in the public interest as it will provide clear regulations in the Person County Solar Energy System Ordinance. The proposed text amendment meets the Comprehensive Land Use Plan Guiding Principle 2, which states to facilitate sustainable economic growth. NEW BUSINESS: ITEM #5 (pgs. 161-176) Broadband Infrastructure Inventory Study Findings and Recommendations ……………………………………………… Katherine Cathey ITEM #6 (pgs. 177-179) Appointment to the Juvenile Crime Prevention Council and the Planning Board …………………………………………………….. Brenda Reaves CHAIRMAN’S REPORT MANAGER’S REPORT COMMISSIONER REPORTS/COMMENTS CLOSED SESSION #1 A motion to enter into Closed Session per General Statute 143-318.11(a)(5) to establish, or to instruct the public body's staff or negotiating agents concerning the position to be taken by or on behalf of the public body in negotiating the price and other material terms of a contract or proposed contract for the acquisition of real property by purchase, option, exchange, or lease with the following individuals permitted to attend: County Attorney, Ellis Hankins, County Manager, Heidi York, Clerk to the Board, Brenda Reaves, Assistant County Manager, Katherine Cathey, Planning Director, Lori Oakley, and John Hill, Director of Arts, Parks and Recreation. CLOSED SESSION #2 A motion to enter into Closed Session per General Statute 143-318.11(a)(4) for the purpose of discussion of matters relating to the location or expansion of industries or other businesses in the area served by the public body, including agreement on a tentative list of economic development incentives that may be offered by the public body in negotiations with the following individuals permitted to attend: Economic Development Director, Sherry Wilborn, County Attorney, Ellis Hankins, County Manager, Heidi York and Clerk to the Board, Brenda Reaves. Note: All Items on the Agenda are for Discussion and Action as deemed appropriate by the Board. 3 NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING The Person County Board of Commissioners will hold a public hearing on Monday, February 7, 2022 at 7:00 p.m. in the Auditorium of the Person County Office Building at 304 South Morgan Street, Roxboro, North Carolina, to hear the following: Petition SUP-05-21 - A request by the applicant, Parallel Infrastructure, LLC (Kelly Young) on behalf of the property owner, Estate of Lonnie Luxton and Carol Luxton, to construct a new 305’ tall self-supported wireless communications tower on 69 acres located at 700 Pixley Pritchard Rd. (Tax Map and Parcel number A84-14) in the RC (Rural Conservation) and B2 (Neighborhood Shopping) Zoning Districts. The public is invited to attend the meeting. Substantial changes may occur to the request based on comments from the public hearing. The Board of Commissioners reserves the right to recess the public hearing at another place and time. For further information on the case(s) listed above, please contact the Person County Planning and Zoning Department at (336) 597-1750. 4 Special Use PermitSUP-05-215 Special Use PermitSUP-05-21– Explanation of RequestPetition SUP-05-21 -A request by the applicant, Parallel Infrastructure, LLC(Kelly Young) on behalf of the property owner, Estate of Lonnie Luxton and CarolLuxton, to construct a new 305’ tall self-supported wireless communicationstower on 69 acres located at 700 Pixley Pritchard Rd. (Tax Map and Parcelnumber A84-14) in the RC (Rural Residential) and B2 (Neighborhood Shopping)Zoning Districts.6 Site Plan7 8 Setbacks, Front, Sides and Rear from Property Lines.9 An aerial view of surrounding properties.To the North: Wooded areas, several single family dwellings.To the East: Mix of wooded and pastureland, one single family dwelling on the adjoining tract.To the South: Vacant Woodlands.To the West: Mix of wooded and pastureland, several single family dwellings, and an existing 250’ wireless communications tower that was erected in 2000.10 Zoning for the property is RC (Rural Conservation) and B2 (Neighborhood Shopping).The surrounding properties are also RC or B2 or a mixture of both.11 General Map of the property showing the location in relation to Pixley Pritchard Road and Oxford Rd.12 Future Land Use MapThe Future Land Use Map for Person County depicts this area as Rural which promotes the protection of agricultural lands and natural resources while allowing low density residential development. Rural future land uses permit neighborhood-scale commercial development at and within 1000 feet of major intersections. Typical rural commercial enterprises, Agricultural and agricultural-support uses are to be permitted throughout this area without limitation.13 Special Use PermitSUP-05-21 – Planning Staff Analysis■The parcel is zoned RC (Rural Conservation) and B2 (Neighborhood Shopping). A communications tower is an allowed use in these zoning districts after obtaining a Special Use Permit.■A reduction in setback to at least one-half the height of the tower is allowed due to the tower being self-supported. A certified fall zone letter is required, has been submitted and is on file.14 Special Use PermitSUP-05-21 – Planning Staff Summary■The proposed site plan meets the requirements of the Person County Planning and Zoning Ordinance regarding Radio, Telephone and Transmitting Towers, specifically Appendix C, Note 9.■The proposed tower has gained approval from the Federal Communications Commission and that the “construction and placement of the tower will not interfere with public safety communications or with the usual and customary transmission or reception of radio, television or other communications services”. Approval letter is on file.15 Special Use PermitSUP-05-21 – Planning Staff SummaryPlanning staff recommends that if the Board approves the request, the following conditions be placed on the Special Use Permit:•The applicant is to obtain all necessary permits for the wireless communications tower project and adhere to all requirements listed in the Person County Planning and Zoning Ordinance. 16 Special Use PermitSUP-05-21 – Findings of Fact■The Board will vote to approve, approve with conditions, or to deny therequested Special Use Permit.■The Board will need to address the Findings of Fact in Section 155 of thePerson County Planning Ordinance and whether this proposal is in keepingwith the Person County Land Use Plan. The Findings of Fact in Section 155-3(b) are as follows:17 Findings of Fact1. That the use will not materially endanger the public health or safety if located where proposed and developed according to the plan as submitted and approved.2. That the use meets all required conditions and specifications.3. That the use will not substantially injure the value of adjoining or abutting property, or that the use is a public necessity, and4. That the location and character of the use, if developed according to the plan as submitted and approved, will be in harmony with the area in which it is to be located and in general conformity with the Comprehensive Plan.18 AGENDA ABSTRACT Meeting Date: February 7, 2022 Agenda Title: Petition SUP-05-21 - A request by the applicant, Parallel Infrastructure, LLC (Kelly Young) on behalf of the property owner, Estate of Lonnie Luxton and Carol Luxton, to construct a new 305’ tall, self-supported wireless communications tower on 69 acres located at 700 Pixley Pritchard Rd (Tax Map and Parcel number A84-14) in the RC (Rural Conservation) and B2 (Neighborhood Shopping) Zoning Districts. Quasi-Judicial Zoning Decision: The special use permit requires a quasi-judicial public hearing. Witnesses are to be sworn in and they are subject to cross-examination. There shall be no ex parte communication without full disclosure at the hearing. The case also requires the review of four Findings of Fact from Section 155 of the Planning Ordinance. Summary of Information: The applicant is requesting to construct a wireless communication tower 305’ tall on property zoned RC (Rural Conservation) and B2 (Neighborhood Shopping) that is located within the Falls Lake Stormwater area. There is an existing 250’ tall telecommunications tower on the adjoining parcel to the west that is located approximately 1300’ from the proposed new tower. The proposed wireless communications tower will be triangular, self-supporting, and sits within a 60’ x 60’ area enclosed by a 6’ high chain link fence. The entire leased area is 100’ x 100’ and will be accessed from Pixley Pritchard Road by a 30’ wide gravel access utility easement. The enclosed 60’ x 60’ area will house the tower base as well as equipment areas for future carriers. A reduction in setback to one-half of the required height is allowed per the Person County Planning and Zoning Ordinance, Note 9, if the applicant provides a letter from an engineer certifying that the fall zone is to be less than the height of the tower. The Person County Land Use Plan identifies the site as Rural, which allows for low-density residential development (lot size minimum 1 acre) or allowing higher density residential development utilizing conservation subdivisions. Rural type neighborhood-scale commercial development at and within 1,000 19 feet of major intersections as well as agricultural and agricultural-support uses are also allowed. Typical rural commercial enterprises should be permitted throughout this area without limitation. Appendix O of the Joint Comprehensive Land Use Plan lists goals and objectives for the county including the following:  Guiding Principle 4: Celebrating Our Rural Character and Lifestyle  Objective 1 (5) Provide enhanced services for rural communities. Planning Staff Summary: Planning staff recommends that if the Board approves the request, the following condition be placed on the Special Use Permit: 1. The applicant is to obtain all necessary permits (zoning, and stormwater) for the wireless communications tower project and adhere to all requirements listed in the Person County Planning and Zoning Ordinance. The Planning Board no longer reviews special use permits. Recommended Action: Vote to approve, approve with conditions, or deny the requested Special Use Permit. The Board will need to address the Findings of Fact in Section 155 of the Person County Planning Ordinance and whether this proposal is in keeping with the Person County Land Use Plan. The Findings of Fact in Section 155-3 (b) are as follows: 1. That the use will not materially endanger the public health or safety if located where proposed and developed according to the plan as submitted and approved. 2. That the use meets all required conditions and specifications. 3. That the use will not substantially injure the value of adjoining or abutting property, or that the use is a public necessity, and 4. That the location and character of the use if developed according to the plan as submitted and approved will be in harmony with the area in which it is to be located and in general conformity with the comprehensive plan. Submitted by: Lori Oakley, Planning Director 20 SPECIAL USE PERMIT APPLICATION Person County Planning & Zoning Fee: $250 + $10/acre 325 S. Morgan Street, Suite B Date Received Roxboro, NC 27573 (336) 597-1750 Application Number APPLICANT INFORMATION Name: Parallel Infrastructure LLC Telephone: _2---'6'--'7_---'9---'0-'7_---'9_0_2--'9 ______ _ Mailing Address: c/o T-Squared Site Services, 2500 Highland Road, Suite 201 City: Hermitage State: __ P_A _______ Zip: _1_6_1_4_8 ___ _ Email: Kelly .Young@WirelessSiting.com Fax: ____________ _ , PROPERTY OWNER INFORMATION Estate of Lonnie Luxton & Carol Luxton 336 592 3442 Name: _______________________ Telephone: -- Mailing Address: 9618 Hampton Road City: Rougemont State: __ N_C _______ Zip: 27572 Email: lonnieluxton@yahoo.com Fax: ____________ _ REQUEST Applicant is requesting a special use permit to install a 305' self support wireless telecommunications tower within a 100' x 100' lease equipment compound area at grade. PROPERTY INFORMATION Address: 700 Pixley Pritchard Road City: _T_im_b_e_rl_a_ke _____ State: _N_c __ Zip: 27583 Tax Map & Parcel Number: _A_8_4_1_4 _____ Total Acreage: 69 Township: Timberlake Zoning District: RC-Rural Conservation WatershedFLAT-BW ,Neuse/Falls Floodplain: Ix] Yes O No Utilities (check all that apply): O Public Sewer O Public Water 0 Septic O Well None CONDITIONS FOR APPROVAL Section 155-3: The Board of Commissioners shall consider the (special use permit) application at a public hearing at which all interested persons shall be permitted to testify. This hearing shall be used to gather competent, material, and substantial evidence to establish the facts of the case. Testimony heard shall be under oath. The Special Use Permit, if granted, shall include such approved plans as may be required. Please state how your request will meet each of the Four Findings of Fact listed below (please attach additional sheets if necessary). 1) That the use will not materially endanger the public health or safety if located where proposed and developed according to the plan as submitted and approved. The proposed telecommunications tower will not materially endanger the public health or safety. The tower will not emit any noise, odor or glares. (2) That the use meets all required conditions and specifications. The proposed telecommunications tower meets all required conditions and specifications of the Ordinance including Note 9. (3) That the use will not substantially injure the value of adjoining or abutting property, or that the use is a public necessity, and The proposed telecommunications tower will not injure the value of adjoining or abutting property and will provide an enhanced benefit to the Timberlake community and surrounding area by providing cell phone coverage. PAGE 1 21 CONDITIONS FOR APPROVAL Continued (4) That the location and character of the use if developed according to the plan as submitted and approved will be in harmony with the area in which it is to be located and in general conformity with comprehensive plan. The proposed location of the telecommunications tower will be in harmony with the area and in general conformity with the comprehensive plan since the tower is proposed in a R-C zone and the leased area will allow for continued use and enJoyment of the other areas of the property. SITE PLAN REQUIREMENTS Ten {10) printed copies and one {1) digital copy of a site plan prepared by a North Carolina registered land surveyor, engineer, or architect must be submitted with this application. The site plan, drawn to scale, shall depict the following: 1. The boundary of the lot(s} to be developed labeled with bearings and distances, total gross land area, location of easement(s), utilities, adjacent road name(s} and number(s}; 2. Name of project, property owner and applicant, vicinity map, north arrow, scale, date of plan preparation and subsequent revisions dates; 3. Topography of site, at contour interval no greater than ten (10} feet, location of perennial and intermittent waters, 100-year floodplains; 4. Location and approximate size of all existing and proposed buildings and structures within the site and existing buildings and structures within five hundred feet adjacent thereto; S. Proposed points of ingress and egress together with the proposed pattern of internal circulation; 6. Existing and proposed parking spaces; 7. Proposed provisions for water supply and sewage disposal; 8. If the site. is located in a designated drinking water supply watershed, the plan shall also: a. Depict the location of existing (labeled according to the date of establishment) and proposed impervious surfaces and respective totals in square feet; b. The total land area of the lot(s) outside of the road right-of-way(s) in square feet. The property owner and/or applicant shall have the burden of proving that the proposed special use will not materially injure the value of adjoining or abutting property. 9. In addition to requirements listed above, a Special Use Permit site plan for a radio, telephone or television tower must show compliance with Note 9 of the Planning Ordinance. (Amended 7/1/2002} 10. In addition to requirements listed above and those listed in Section 81 of this Ordinance, a Special Use Permit site plan for a camper/recreational vehicle park must show compliance with the following: a. A minimum lot size of two acres is required. b. Density to be 2500 square feet for each tent or trailer space. c. A minimum undisturbed fifty-foot buffer from all property lines . d. Each campsite shall contain a stabilized parking pad of either pavement or gravel and one off-street parking space. e. A sanitary source of drinking water shall be not more than 200 feet, toilet facilities not more than 400 feet and wash houses not more than 1500 feet from any tent or trailer space. This provision shall not apply where community water and sewer connections are provided to trailers having self-contained kitchens and bathroom facilities. (Added 8/2/2010) , SIGNATURES AND ACKNOWLEDGEMENT The undersigned hereby certify that the forgoing application is complete and accurate. Furthermore, the undersigned hereby aut orizes Person County Planning Director or designated representative to enter upon the above referenced property r the P, se of inspecting and verifying compliance with Person County's Ordinances. 12/3/21 Date See attached Owner's Consent Form Signature of Property Owner Date PAGE 2 22 Pa INFRASTRUCTURE •ir.pte r11b1.H 10, 2021 Person County Planning & Zonlng 325 S. Morgan Streett Suite B Roxboro, NC 27573 KE: Lotter of Consent from Property Owner Parallel Towers Ill, LLC at Parcel: 0934-00-44-9158.000, 6241 Oxford, Timberlake, NC 27583 Tower ID: l 5463112/PINC400 To Whom it may concern, I arn the owner of the above-mentioned property and my signature below gi\ms consent to Parallel lowers 111, LCC (Tenant} and their sub-tenants to file for all permits for the above-mentioned te l,ecor\"\munications facility. Carol a. Luxton By: f.}11-;<1..:tt (6_ _q$·,,,i/_~ Print Nnme: Carol B. Luxton I l,--,,1 Ln V./~" .. 1 Its~ Cttt!l.a -. -c fY Respectfully, Evelyn M. Radowicz Evelyn M. RijcJowicz Project Manager Parallel l11fr;Jstructure 15105 John J. Delaney Drivt1 Suite D-3 Cllartottc, NC 28277 M: tl13-658-il815 evPl)'n.radowicz@p1t~wers.com I 't'WW,pltower~.cor.11 Para tNrRASTRUCTURE PJ\RAI.LFL INH~ASTRUCTURE, LLC 28277 l510S John J. DPtaney Drive, SL11te D 3,Ch,trlottc, NC 23 24 SUP-05-21 Staff Analysis Board of Commissioners February 7, 2022 1    Special Use Permit SUP-05-21 Parallel Infrastructure, LLC Wireless Communication Tower EXPLANATION OF REQUEST Petition SUP-05-21 - A request by the applicant, Parallel Infrastructure, LLC (Kelly Young) on behalf of the property owner, Estate of Lonnie Luxton and Carol Luxton, to construct a new 305’ tall self-supported wireless communications tower on 69 acres located at 700 Pixley Pritchard Rd. (Tax Map and Parcel number A84-14) in the RC (Rural Conservation) and B2 (Neighborhood Shopping) Zoning Districts. LOCATION AND CURRENT LAND USE This tract is located at 700 Pixley Pritchard Rd in Timberlake, NC and is zoned RC (Rural Conservation) and B2 (Neighborhood Shopping). It is within the Neuse Watershed and Falls Lake Stormwater Area, and is a mixture of woodlands and pastureland. The property contains one single-family dwelling and a family cemetery plot. Condition and land use of the surrounding properties are:  To the North – Wooded areas and several single-family dwellings, RC (Rural Conservation) zoning.  To the East – A mixture of wooded areas and pastureland, one single-family dwelling on the adjoining tract, RC (Rural Conservation) zoning.  To the South – Mostly wooded vacant tract of land, part RC (Rural Conservation) and part B2 (Neighborhood Shopping) zoning.  To the West – A mixture of wooded areas and pastureland, several single-family dwellings, part RC (Rural Conservation) and part B2 (Neighborhood Shopping) zoning. There is also an existing 250’ tall telecommunications tower on the adjoining parcel to the west that is located approximately 1300’ from the proposed new tower. LAND USE / SITE PLAN  The property is zoned RC (Rural Conservation) and B2 (Neighborhood Shopping), and the Person County Permitted Use Table lists a Radio, Telephone and TV Transmitting Tower or Wireless Communication Tower as an allowed use within the RC (Rural Conservation) and the B2 (Neighborhood Shopping) zoning districts with a Special Use Permit.  The proposed wireless communications tower will be triangular, self-supporting, and sits within a 60’ x 60’ area enclosed by a 6’ high chain link fence. The entire leased area is 100’ x 100’ and it will be accessed from Pixley Pritchard Rd by a 20’ wide access and utility easement.  The enclosed 60’ x 60’ area will house the tower base as well as equipment areas for future carriers.   COMPREHENSIVE PLAN The Person County Joint Comprehensive Land Use Plan identifies the proposed tracts as Rural. Rural is defined as: 25 SUP-05-21 Staff Analysis Board of Commissioners February 7, 2022 2    The Rural future land use category is intended to promote the protection of agricultural lands and natural resources while allowing low-density residential development (minimum lot size of one acre). Cluster or conservation subdivisions, which permit higher density residential development while setting aside land for preservation, should also be permitted in Rural areas. The Rural future land use category should permit neighborhood-scale commercial development at, and within 1,000 feet of, major intersections, (examples include Timberlake, Olive Hill, Hurdle Mills, etc.). Development regulations should limit floor area of retail and similar uses in these rural commercial nodes. Agricultural and agricultural-support uses, along with other typical rural commercial enterprises should be permitted throughout these areas, without limitation. Appendix O of the Person County Joint Comprehensive Land Use Plan lists Guiding Principles and objectives for the County including the following relevant statements: Guiding Principal 4, Objective 1- Celebrating Our Rural Character and Lifestyle.  Objective 1 (5) – Provide enhanced services for rural communities. PLANNING STAFF ANALYSIS The parcel is zoned RC (Rural Conservation) and B2 (Neighborhood Shopping) and a wireless communications tower is an allowed use in both zoning districts after obtaining a Special Use Permit. A reduction in setback to at least one-half the height of the tower is allowed due to the tower being self- supported. A certified fall zone letter is required and is on file. A significant portion of this tract is identified by FEMA as being within the AE Flood Zone, or as having a 1% chance of flooding. According to the site plan for the tower, the tower itself will be located completely outside of the flood zone. PLANNING STAFF SUMMARY The proposed site plan meets the requirements of the Person County Planning and Zoning Ordinance regarding Radio, Telephone and Transmitting Towers, specifically Appendix C, Note 9. The applicant has provided a letter of approval from the Federal Communications Commission and that the “construction and placement of the tower will not interfere with public safety communications or with the usual and customary transmission or reception of radio, television or other communications services”. Planning staff recommends that if the Board approves the request, the following conditions be placed on the Special Use Permit: 1. The applicant is to obtain all necessary permits (zoning, and stormwater) for the wireless communications tower project and adhere to all requirements listed in the Person County Planning and Zoning Ordinance. 26 SUP-05-21 Staff Analysis Board of Commissioners February 7, 2022 3    In approving an application for a special use permit, the Board of Commissioners may attach fair and reasonable conditions to the approval. The petitioner will have a reasonable opportunity to consider and respond to any additional requirements prior to approval or denial by the Board. The Board shall issue a special use permit if it has evaluated an application and determined: 1. That the use will not materially endanger the public health or safety if located where proposed and developed according to the plan as submitted and approved; 2. That the use meets all of the required conditions and specifications; 3. That the use will not substantially injure the value of adjoining or abutting property, or that the use is a public necessity; 4. That the location and character of the use, if developed according to the plan as submitted and approved, will be in harmony with the area in which it is to be located and in general conformity with the Comprehensive Plan. ***Please refer to the 4 Findings of Fact listed above when making a decision*** Submitted by: Angela Blount, Planner I 27 A84 87A84 87A84 135A84 135 A84 14A84 14 A84A84194194 A84 85A84 85 A84A B 2A84A B 2 A84 21A84 21 A84A845454A84A84178178 A84A841919 A84 145A84 145 A84 93A84 93 A84 23A84 23 A84 97A84 97 A84 209A84 209 A84A A 5A84A A 5 A84 41A84 41 A84A8421A21A A84A84224224 A84A846767 A84 133A84 133 A84AA84AB 18B 18 A84A84223223 A84 176A84 176 A84 207A84 207 A84A A 1A84A A 1 A84 276A84 276 A84 203A84 203A84 88A84 88 A84A A 8A84A A 8 A84 84A84 84 A84 117A84 117A84 146A84 146 A84 232A84 232 A84A A 12A84A A 12 A84 197A84 197 A84AA84AA 10A 10 A84AA84AA 7A 7 A84 83A84 83 A84 95A84 95 A84AA84AB 5B 5 A84 174A84 174 A84 94A84 94 A84 68A84 68 A84 22A84 22 A84A848282 A84 13A84 13 A84A B 16A84A B 16 A84 98A84 98 A84A841818 A84A84175175 A84A A 2A84A A 2 A84 278A84 278 A84 208A84 208 A84A84177177 A84A84195195 A84A B 3A84A B 3 A84A843333A84 33A84 33 A84 33A84 33 A84 32A84 32 A84 138A84 138 A84A A 13A84A A 13 A84A84234234 A84 96A84 96 A84 52A84 52 A84 136A84 136 A84A A 6A84A A 6 A84A A 3A84A A 3 A84A B 4A84A B 4 A84A84196196A84 188A84 188 A84 11A84 11 A84 113A84 113 A84AA84AA 14A 14 A84AA84AB 1B 1 A84 225A84 225 A84 40A84 40 A84A A 9A84A A 9 £¤158 Oxford RdOxford Rd PP iixx llee yy PP rr iitt cc hh aa rr dd RR dd Aerial MapSUP 05-21Parallel Infrastructure LLCKelly Young ¯ Highway Secondary Local A84 14 Person Parcels 1 inch = 500 feet 28 A84 87A84 87A84 135A84 135 A84 14A84 14 A84A84194194 A84 85A84 85 A84A B 2A84A B 2 A84 21A84 21 A84A845454A84A84178178 A84A841919 A84 145A84 145 A84 93A84 93 A84 23A84 23 A84 97A84 97 A84 209A84 209 A84A A 5A84A A 5 A84 41A84 41 A84A8421A21A A84A84224224 A84A846767 A84 133A84 133 A84AA84AB 18B 18 A84A84223223 A84 176A84 176 A84 207A84 207 A84A A 1A84A A 1 A84 276A84 276 A84 203A84 203A84 88A84 88 A84A A 8A84A A 8 A84 84A84 84 A84 117A84 117A84 146A84 146 A84 232A84 232 A84A A 12A84A A 12 A84 197A84 197 A84AA84AA 10A 10 A84AA84AA 7A 7 A84 83A84 83 A84 95A84 95 A84AA84AB 5B 5 A84 174A84 174 A84 94A84 94 A84 68A84 68 A84 22A84 22 A84A848282 A84 13A84 13 A84A B 16A84A B 16 A84 98A84 98 A84A841818 A84A84175175 A84A A 2A84A A 2 A84 278A84 278 A84 208A84 208 A84A84177177 A84A84195195 A84A B 3A84A B 3 A84A843333A84 33A84 33 A84 33A84 33 A84 32A84 32 A84 138A84 138 A84A A 13A84A A 13 A84A84234234 A84 96A84 96 A84 52A84 52 A84 136A84 136 A84A A 6A84A A 6 A84A A 3A84A A 3 A84A B 4A84A B 4 A84A84196196A84 188A84 188 A84 11A84 11 A84 113A84 113 A84AA84AA 14A 14 A84AA84AB 1B 1 A84 225A84 225 A84 40A84 40 A84A A 9A84A A 9 £¤158 Oxford RdOxford Rd PP iixx llee yy PP rr iitt cc hh aa rr dd RR dd FLU MapSUP 05-21Parallel Infrastructure LLCKelly Young ¯ Highway Secondary Local A84 14 Person Parcels Residential Neighborhoods Rural 1 inch = 500 feet 29 A84 87A84 87A84 135A84 135 A84 14A84 14 A84A84194194 A84 85A84 85 A84A B 2A84A B 2 A84 21A84 21 A84A845454A84A84178178 A84 19A84 19 A84 145A84 145 A84 93A84 93 A84 23A84 23 A84 97A84 97 A84 209A84 209 A84A A 5A84A A 5 A84 41A84 41 A84A8421A21A A84A84224224 A84 67A84 67 A84 133A84 133 A84AA84AB 18B 18 A84A84223223 A84 176A84 176 A84 207A84 207 A84A A 1A84A A 1 A84 276A84 276 A84 203A84 203A84 88A84 88 A84A A 8A84A A 8 A84 84A84 84 A84 117A84 117 A84 146A84 146 A84 232A84 232 A84A A 12A84A A 12 A84 197A84 197 A84AA84AA 10A 10 A84AA84AA 7A 7 A84 83A84 83 A84 95A84 95 A84AA84AB 5B 5 A84 174A84 174 A84 94A84 94 A84 68A84 68 A84 22A84 22 A84A848282 A84 13A84 13 A84A B 16A84A B 16 A84 98A84 98 A84A841818 A84A84175175 A84A A 2A84A A 2 A84 278A84 278 A84 208A84 208 A84A84177177 A84A84195195 A84A B 3A84A B 3 A84 33A84 33 A84 33A84 33 A84 32A84 32 A84 138A84 138 A84A A 13A84A A 13 A84A84234234 A84 96A84 96 A84 52A84 52 A84 136A84 136 A84A A 6A84A A 6 A84A A 3A84A A 3 A84A B 4A84A B 4 A84A84196196A84 188A84 188 A84 11A84 11 A84 113A84 113 A84AA84AB 1B 1 A84 225A84 225 A84 40A84 40 A84A A 9A84A A 9 £¤158 Oxford RdOxford Rd PP iixx llee yy PP rr iitt cc hh aa rr dd RR dd General MapSUP 05-21Parallel Infrastructure LLCKelly Young ¯ Highway Secondary Local A84 14 Person Parcels 1 inch = 500 feet 30 A84 87A84 87A84 135A84 135 A84 14A84 14 A84A84194194 A84 85A84 85 A84A B 2A84A B 2 A84 21A84 21 A84A845454A84A84178178 A84 19A84 19 A84 145A84 145 A84 93A84 93 A84 23A84 23 A84 97A84 97 A84 209A84 209 A84A A 5A84A A 5 A84 41A84 41 A84A8421A21A A84A84224224 A84 67A84 67 A84 133A84 133 A84AA84AB 18B 18 A84A84223223 A84 176A84 176 A84 207A84 207 A84A A 1A84A A 1 A84 276A84 276 A84 203A84 203A84 88A84 88 A84A A 8A84A A 8 A84 84A84 84 A84 117A84 117 A84 146A84 146 A84 232A84 232 A84A A 12A84A A 12 A84 197A84 197 A84AA84AA 10A 10 A84AA84AA 7A 7 A84 83A84 83 A84 95A84 95 A84AA84AB 5B 5 A84 174A84 174 A84 94A84 94 A84 68A84 68 A84 22A84 22 A84A848282 A84 13A84 13 A84A B 16A84A B 16 A84 98A84 98 A84A841818 A84A84175175 A84A A 2A84A A 2 A84 278A84 278 A84 208A84 208 A84A84177177 A84A84195195 A84A B 3A84A B 3 A84 33A84 33 A84 33A84 33 A84 32A84 32 A84 138A84 138 A84A A 13A84A A 13 A84A84234234 A84 96A84 96 A84 52A84 52 A84 136A84 136 A84A A 6A84A A 6 A84A A 3A84A A 3 A84A B 4A84A B 4 A84A84196196A84 188A84 188 A84 11A84 11 A84 113A84 113 A84AA84AB 1B 1 A84 225A84 225 A84 40A84 40 A84A A 9A84A A 9 £¤158 Oxford RdOxford Rd PP iixx llee yy PP rr iitt cc hh aa rr dd RR dd Zoning MapSUP 05-21Parallel Infrastructure LLCKelly Young ¯ Highway Secondary Local A84 14 Person Parcels R: Residential B-1: Highway Commercial B-2: Neighborhood Shopping GI: General Industrial R-C: Rural Conservation AP: Airport Overlay 1 inch = 500 feet 31 32 33 34 35 36 SITE INFORMATION 700 PIXLEY PRITCHARD ROAD TIMBERLAKE, NC 27583 T-1 SITE NAME: OXFORD PROPOSED 305' SELF-SUPPORT TOWER 112.02.21ADDRESS UPDATE TM 008.30.21ISSUED FOR REVIEW TM 1 46172 PI TOWER ID# : PINC400 NEW FA #: 15463112 36.346847° -78.881089° COPYRIGHT 2021 T-SQUARED SITE SERVICES, LLCC THESE DOCUMENTS ARE CONFIDENTIAL AND ARE THE SOLE PROPERTY OF PARALLEL INFRASTRUCTURE AND MAY NOT BE REPRODUCED,DISSEMINATED OR REDISTRIBUTED WITHOUT THE EXPRESS WRITTENCONSENT OF PARALLEL INFRASTRUCTURE. HERMITAGE, PA 16148 www.t-sqrd.com 2500 HIGHLAND ROAD, SUITE 201 T-SQUARED SITE SERVICES HERMITAGE, PA 16148 www.t-sqrd.com T-SQUARED SITE SERVICES 2500 HIGHLAND ROAD, SUITE 201 724.308.7855724.308.7855 Parallel Para e PROJECT TEAM DRAWING INDEX SHEET SHEET DESCRIPTION PROJECT DESCRIPTION THE PURPOSE OF THIS PROJECT IS TO ENHANCE BROADBAND CONNECTIVITY AND CAPACITY TO THE EXISTING ELIGIBLE WIRELESS FACILITY. THE PARTIES ABOVE HEREBY APPROVE AND ACCEPT THESE DOCUMENTS AND AUTHORIZE THE CONTRACTOR TO PROCEED WITH THE CONSTRUCTION DESCRIBED HEREIN. ALL CONSTRUCTION DOCUMENTS ARE SUBJECT TO REVIEW BY THE LOCAL BUILDING DEPARTMENT AND ANY CHANGES AND MODIFICATIONS THE MAY IMPOSE. LOCATION MAP APPLICABLE CODES / REFERENCE DOCUMENTS CALL NORTH CAROLINA ONE CALL (800) 632-4949 CALL 3 WORKING DAYS BEFORE YOU DIG! PI TOWER ID:PINC400 AT&T SITE NAME:OXFORD SITE ADDRESS:700 PIXLEY PRITCHARD ROAD TIMBERLAKE, NC 27583 COUNTY:PERSON E-911 ADDRESS:700 PIXLEY PRITCHARD RD, TIMBERLAKE, NC 27583 AREA OF CONSTRUCTION: RAWLAND LATITUDE:36.346847° LONGITUDE:-78.881089° LAT/LONG TYPE:NAD83 JURISDICTION:PERSON COUNTY OCCUPANCY CLASSIFICATION: U TYPE OF CONSTRUCTION:11B A.D.A. COMPLIANCE:FACILITY IS UNMANNED AND NOT FOR HUMAN HABITATION LAND OWNER:CAROL B. LUXTON 9618 HAMPTON RD ROUGEMONT, NC 27527 TOWER OWNER: PARALLEL TOWERS III, LLC 15105 JOHN J. DELANEY DRIVE SUITE D-3 CHARLOTTE, NC 28277 PI TOWER ID: PINC400 NEW FA SITE #: 15463112 AT&T SITE NAME: OXFORD SITE ADDRESS: 700 PIXLEY PRITCHARD ROAD TIMBERLAKE, NC 27583 JURISDICTION: PERSON COUNTY SITE TYPE: 305' SELF-SUPPORT E-911 ADDRESS: 700 PIXLEY PRITCHARD RD, TIMBERLAKE, NC 27583 ·INSTALL 305' SELF-SUPPORT TOWER ·INSTALL CHAIN LINK FENCING ·INSTALL (1) UTILITY H-FRAME ·INSTALL (2) FIBER VAULTS ·INSTALL ACCESS ROAD T-1 TITLE SHEET DIRECTIONS: Z-1 ENLARGED SITE PLAN ALL DRAWINGS CONTAINED HEREIN ARE FORMATTED FOR 11X17 CONTRACTOR SHALL VERIFY ALL PLANS, EXISTING DIMENSIONS AND CONDITIONS ON THE JOB SITE AND SHALL IMMEDIATELY NOTIFY THE ENGINEER IN WRITING OF ANY DISCREPANCIES BEFORE PROCEEDING WITH THE WORK OR BE RESPONSIBLE FOR SAME. ELEVATION Z-2 SURVEY SURVEY PLAT Z-3 SITE PLAN ELECTRICAL SERVICE PROVIDER: DUKE ENERGY 1-866-582-6345 TELCO PROVIDER:TBD PARALLEL INFRASTRUCTURE ZONING DRAWINGSTITLE SHEET Parallel Para e ALL WORK AND MATERIALS SHALL BE PERFORMED AND INSTALLED IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE CURRENT EDITIONS OF THE FOLLOWING CODES AS ADOPTED BY THE LOCAL GOVERNING AUTHORITIES. NOTHING IN THESE PLANS IS TO BE CONSTRUCTED TO PERMIT WORK NOT CONFORMING TO THE LATEST EDITIONS OF THE FOLLOWING CODES. ·2015 INTERNATIONAL BUILDING CODE ·2017 NATIONAL ELECTRIC CODE ·2015 INTERNATIONAL ENERGY CONSERVATION CODE ·2015 INTERNATIONAL EXISTING BUILDING CODE ·2015 INTERNATIONAL GREEN CONSTRUCTION CODE ·2015 INTERNATIONAL MECHANICAL CODE ·2015 INTERNATIONAL RESIDENTIAL CODE Z-4 MAP SITE PLAN 37 38 39 700 PIXLEY PRITCHARD ROAD TIMBERLAKE, NC 27583 Z-1 SITE NAME: OXFORD PROPOSED 305' SELF-SUPPORT TOWER 112.02.21ADDRESS UPDATE TM 008.30.21ISSUED FOR REVIEW TM 1 46172 PI TOWER ID# : PINC400 NEW FA #: 15463112 36.346847° -78.881089° COPYRIGHT 2021 T-SQUARED SITE SERVICES, LLCC THESE DOCUMENTS ARE CONFIDENTIAL AND ARE THE SOLE PROPERTY OF PARALLEL INFRASTRUCTURE AND MAY NOT BE REPRODUCED,DISSEMINATED OR REDISTRIBUTED WITHOUT THE EXPRESS WRITTENCONSENT OF PARALLEL INFRASTRUCTURE. HERMITAGE, PA 16148 www.t-sqrd.com 2500 HIGHLAND ROAD, SUITE 201 T-SQUARED SITE SERVICES HERMITAGE, PA 16148 www.t-sqrd.com T-SQUARED SITE SERVICES 2500 HIGHLAND ROAD, SUITE 201 724.308.7855724.308.7855 Parallel Para e N SITE PLAN 40 700 PIXLEY PRITCHARD ROAD TIMBERLAKE, NC 27583 Z-2 SITE NAME: OXFORD PROPOSED 305' SELF-SUPPORT TOWER 112.02.21ADDRESS UPDATE TM 008.30.21ISSUED FOR REVIEW TM 1 46172 PI TOWER ID# : PINC400 NEW FA #: 15463112 36.346847° -78.881089° COPYRIGHT 2021 T-SQUARED SITE SERVICES, LLCC THESE DOCUMENTS ARE CONFIDENTIAL AND ARE THE SOLE PROPERTY OF PARALLEL INFRASTRUCTURE AND MAY NOT BE REPRODUCED,DISSEMINATED OR REDISTRIBUTED WITHOUT THE EXPRESS WRITTENCONSENT OF PARALLEL INFRASTRUCTURE. HERMITAGE, PA 16148 www.t-sqrd.com 2500 HIGHLAND ROAD, SUITE 201 T-SQUARED SITE SERVICES HERMITAGE, PA 16148 www.t-sqrd.com T-SQUARED SITE SERVICES 2500 HIGHLAND ROAD, SUITE 201 724.308.7855724.308.7855 Parallel Para e N MAP SITE PLAN 41 700 PIXLEY PRITCHARD ROAD TIMBERLAKE, NC 27583 Z-3 SITE NAME: OXFORD PROPOSED 305' SELF-SUPPORT TOWER 112.02.21ADDRESS UPDATE TM 008.30.21ISSUED FOR REVIEW TM 1 46172 PI TOWER ID# : PINC400 NEW FA #: 15463112 36.346847° -78.881089° COPYRIGHT 2021 T-SQUARED SITE SERVICES, LLCC THESE DOCUMENTS ARE CONFIDENTIAL AND ARE THE SOLE PROPERTY OF PARALLEL INFRASTRUCTURE AND MAY NOT BE REPRODUCED,DISSEMINATED OR REDISTRIBUTED WITHOUT THE EXPRESS WRITTENCONSENT OF PARALLEL INFRASTRUCTURE. HERMITAGE, PA 16148 www.t-sqrd.com 2500 HIGHLAND ROAD, SUITE 201 T-SQUARED SITE SERVICES HERMITAGE, PA 16148 www.t-sqrd.com T-SQUARED SITE SERVICES 2500 HIGHLAND ROAD, SUITE 201 724.308.7855724.308.7855 Parallel Para e N ENLARGED SITE PLAN 42 700 PIXLEY PRITCHARD ROAD TIMBERLAKE, NC 27583 Z-4 SITE NAME: OXFORD PROPOSED 305' SELF-SUPPORT TOWER 112.02.21ADDRESS UPDATE TM 008.30.21ISSUED FOR REVIEW TM 1 46172 PI TOWER ID# : PINC400 NEW FA #: 15463112 36.346847° -78.881089° COPYRIGHT 2021 T-SQUARED SITE SERVICES, LLCC THESE DOCUMENTS ARE CONFIDENTIAL AND ARE THE SOLE PROPERTY OF PARALLEL INFRASTRUCTURE AND MAY NOT BE REPRODUCED,DISSEMINATED OR REDISTRIBUTED WITHOUT THE EXPRESS WRITTENCONSENT OF PARALLEL INFRASTRUCTURE. HERMITAGE, PA 16148 www.t-sqrd.com 2500 HIGHLAND ROAD, SUITE 201 T-SQUARED SITE SERVICES HERMITAGE, PA 16148 www.t-sqrd.com T-SQUARED SITE SERVICES 2500 HIGHLAND ROAD, SUITE 201 724.308.7855724.308.7855 Parallel Para e ELEVATION 43 January 18, 2022 1 PERSON COUNTY BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS JANUARY 18, 2022 MEMBERS PRESENT OTHERS PRESENT Gordon Powell Heidi York, County Manager C. Derrick Sims Brenda B. Reaves, Clerk to the Board Kyle W. Puryear S.Ellis Hankins, County Attorney Charlie Palmer Patricia Gentry The Board of Commissioners for the County of Person, North Carolina, met in regular session on Tuesday, January 18, 2022 at 9:00am in the Person County Office Building Auditorium. Chairman Powell called the meeting to order and offered an invocation. Commissioner Palmer led the group in the Pledge of Allegiance. DISCUSSION/ADJUSTMENT/APPROVAL OF AGENDA: A motion was made by Commissioner Gentry and carried 5-0 to approve the agenda. PUBLIC HEARING: PETITION TA-03-21, A REQUEST BY THE PERSON COUNTY PLANNING DEPT., ON BEHALF OF THE PERSON COUNTY BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS, TO REVISE THE PERSON COUNTY SOLAR ENERGY SYSTEM ORDINANCE: A motion was made by Vice Chairman Sims and carried 5-0 to open the duly advertised public hearing for a request by the Person County Planning Dept., on behalf of the Person County Board of Commissioners, to revise the Person County Solar Energy System Ordinance. Planning Director, Lori Oakley stated all state statutes and planning ordinance requirements have been met for this public hearing and requested that her staff report be entered into the record. 44 January 18, 2022 2 45 January 18, 2022 3 46 January 18, 2022 4 Ms. Oakley shared the following presentation with the group for this public hearing. 47 January 18, 2022 5 48 January 18, 2022 6 49 January 18, 2022 7 50 January 18, 2022 8 51 January 18, 2022 9 52 January 18, 2022 10 Ms. Oakley outlined the concerns related to solar energy systems as follows: Industrial Use -There are no changes proposed to where solar facilities can be located. Buffer Height – The buffer height was increased to 6 ft. from 3 ft. at the time of planting while reducing the buffer width from 150 ft. to 100 ft. That reduction in width will allow for better fire protection around the perimeter of the site while still maintaining the integrity of the buffer since the height was increased. Battery Storage - An additional section was added regarding battery storage and it states that any battery storage containing Poly Flouro-Alkyl Substances (PFAS) technology must be noted in the application. The Planning Board requested the words (Polyflouroalkyl substances) be added to Section 3.1E2c. It is a class of chemical compounds that are used in a variety of industries for their ability to create coatings that are water repellant. PFAS’s are resilient within the environment and typically do no break down over time. An example of a PFAS is Teflon. The new section does state that if a project uses PFAS, it must submit a containment plan and a separate decommissioning plan for those battery storage areas containing PFAS’s. Decommissioning – Person County already had a well written decommissioning section comparable with other jurisdictions. We added that the decommissioning bond needs to be reviewed every five years by an engineer to determine that it is still valid and takes into account any inflation. Size Limitation - I could not find any jurisdiction that had a size limitation on SES and I did not feel comfortable selecting an arbitrary number. The Planning Board discussed this topic at length and did propose additional language regarding a size limitation and distance separation. They proposed to add Section 2.3 Height and Size Limitation B to read: The maximum size of a level 3 solar energy system shall not exceed three hundred (300) acres as measured around the perimeter of the immediate perimeter of the panels and shall not be located within one (1) linear mile of an existing level 3 solar energy system. Effect on the Environment & Wildlife - Research is scarce on how solar facilities affects wildlife. Solar facilities have the potential to deter, attract or be imperceptible to different wildlife species. I did include a requirement for any relevant studies/reports/documentation that might be required by staff or any board member as it pertains to field surveys for state and federal listed species protected under state and federal law. As for the environment, a Phase 1 environmental site assessment shall be submitted with all level 3 applications. A Phase I environmental site assessment looks into the history of a property. The resulting report provides a detailed summary of the environmental history of the property and findings about potential recognized environmental conditions. Also, under the additional information section that can be requested by staff or board members, there is also several environmental reports that can be requested including geological reports, surface water reports, soil surveys and an environmental constraint analysis. An environmental 53 January 18, 2022 11 constraints analysis screens proposed developments for potential issues that may pose a constraint to successful implementation. Photovoltaic Heat island effect - This question has been raised across the US not just in NC and it continues to be studied and examined. As renewable energy continues to surge, will large-scale facilities produce a “heat island” effect, and there is just not definitive data at this time to support that. In fact, some models have suggested that solar energy systems can actually have a cooling effect on the local environment depending on the efficiency and placement of the panels. This area of concern will be continued to be monitored as solar continues to increase. Loss of Farmland - This topic brings me to the term agrivoltaics, the simultaneous use of areas of land for both solar power generation and agriculture. While not as common in US, other countries are raising panel heights slightly in order to grow crops underneath and animals are grazing along the solar panels and I believe we have some of that occurring here in Person County. 54 January 18, 2022 12 55 January 18, 2022 13 56 January 18, 2022 14 Speaking in favor of the request by the Person County Planning Dept., on behalf of the Person County Board of Commissioners, to revise the Person County Solar Energy System Ordinance were the following: Mr. Ray Foushee of 8930 Hurdle Mills Road, Hurdle Mills stated opposition to reducing the 150 ft. buffer to 100 ft. as presented; he noted his preference to have the buffer remain at 150 ft. as well as to add on the 50 ft. right-of-way for emergency vehicles. In addition, Mr. Foushee requested the Board to consider setting the maximum size at 150 acres. Mr. Paul Lynch of 395 Union Grove Church Road, Hurdle Mills requested the Board to consider when setting the maximum size of the solar facilities to define in actual acreage as defined by boundaries versus the perimeter of the panels. In addition, he wanted the Board to increase the 1-mile space between level 3 solar energy systems. There were no individuals appearing before the Board to speak in opposition to the request by the Person County Planning Dept., on behalf of the Person County Board of Commissioners, to revise the Person County Solar Energy System Ordinance. A motion was made by Vice Chairman Sims and carried 5-0 to close the public hearing for the request by the Person County Planning Dept., on behalf of the Person County Board of Commissioners, to revise the Person County Solar Energy System Ordinance. 57 January 18, 2022 15 CONSIDERATION TO GRANT OR DENY REQUEST TO REVISE THE PERSON COUNTY SOLAR ENERGY SYSTEM ORDINANCE: Commissioner Gentry stated that the solar power has to be sold to a power company, which she believes is an industrial use, and by so, she feels the solar systems should not be zoned for use in RC (Rural Conservation.) Commissioner Gentry advocated to change the five-year review by an engineer to a shorter period, i.e., 2 or 3 years. Commissioner Puryear asked staff to bring to the Board any proposed fee(s) that would go along with the Solar Energy System Ordinance, i.e., an annual inspection fee. He agreed with Commissioner Gentry and other board members that 150 acres would be good as a maximum; he stated that 100 acres would be sufficient in his opinion to which other commissioners agreed as well. A motion was made by Commissioner Puryear and carried 5-0 to postpone consideration to revise the Person County Solar Energy System Ordinance to the Board’s next meeting, on February 7, 2022. County Attorney, Ellis Hankins said staff would bring back two versions of the ordinance, 1) the proposed ordinance as presented on this date, and 2) the ordinance with the Board’s proposed amendments. He confirmed another public hearing was not required for the amendments suggested by the Board. Planning Director, Lori Oakley confirmed with the Board the key changes proposed by the Board of Commissioners were as follows:  5-year engineer review to 2 or 3 years  Remove from RC (Rural Conservation) zoning  Keep 150 ft. buffer with an additional 50 ft. open space for emergency vehicles  100 acres maximum size of panels  Proposed fee schedule 58 January 18, 2022 16 INFORMAL COMMENTS: The following individual appeared before the Board to make informal comments: Mr. Chris Weaver of 342 Satterfield Farm Road, Timberlake, NC told the Board that in December he noted an announcement that a semi-conductor facility was looking at Chatham County and that now, Chatham County was no longer in the running for the facility. He told the Board if they were not going to do anything with the Mega Site to just throw in the towel; he said he would be posting on Person County Local’s Face Book page documents related to the Mega Site he received through a public records request. DISCUSSION/ADJUSTMENT/APPROVAL OF CONSENT AGENDA: A motion was made by Commissioner Gentry and carried 5-0 to approve the Consent Agenda with the following items: A. Approval of Minutes of December 6, 2021, B. Budget Amendment #11, C. Commissioner Assignments for 2022, D. Records Retention and Disposition Schedule, and E. Official Written Ordinance approval for Conditional District Rezoning Petition CD-02-21, a request by Kevin Puryear Properties, LLC for a Conditional District Rezoning from Residential to Conditional District Rural Conservation for equipment storage on Tax Map/Parcel Number A25-151 59 January 18, 2022 17 NEW BUSINESS: COMMUNITY SERVICES BLOCK GRANT APPLICATION OVERVIEW: Ms. Alexis Franks, Telamon SE Director of Workforce and Career Services presented to the Board its intent to re-apply for Community Services Block Grant (CSBG) funding from the North Carolina Office of Economic Opportunity for program year 2022- 2023. This funding will allow Telamon’s Project PRIDE to continue to provide support to low-income residents in North Carolina counties of Caswell, Person and Rockingham who are 125% of the Federal Poverty Level or below. An overview of the CSBG program year 2022-2023 follows: Community Services Block Grant Application Overview Program Year 2022-2023 What is Telamon Corporation? Telamon is a 501c3 private nonprofit headquartered in Raleigh, NC. Our mission is to provide educational services that lead to better jobs, better lives, and better communities. Telamon has been in operation for over 50 years. We offer early childhood, employment/training, and housing/financial services. What are Community Services Block Grant Funds (CSBG)? CSBG funds are federal dollars that are used to address the causes and conditions of poverty in communities. North Carolina’s Division of Social Services’ Office of Economic Opportunity administers these funds in our state. CSBG funds are allocated to Community Action Agencies. What are Community Action Agencies (CAA)? CAA is the national name for the entities that are designated to carry out CSBG-funded services in all 50 states and Puerto Rico. In North Carolina CSBG funds are designated in all 100 NC counties. Telamon Corporation is designated to receive CSBG funds to serve three (3) NC counties: Rockingham, Caswell, and Person. An 18-member Advisory Council, with membership from these three counties, provides oversight of the CSBG allocation. Why Are Public Meetings Held? As a CAA, Telamon must follow a process governed by NC Administrative Code 10A NCAC 97B.0402(3). The process requires us to inform communities about how we propose using the CSBG funds that we have been allocated, and to solicit citizen views and comments. 60 January 18, 2022 18 Who is Eligible for CSBG-funded Services? Low-income families with incomes at or below 125% of the federal poverty guidelines may be eligible. What is Telamon’s CSBG Funding Allocation? Telamon received an allocation for FY22/23 of $422,503 broken out in the following amounts: Caswell County $55,997; Person County $97,694; and Rockingham County $268,812. What is Telamon’s Plan for Spending this CSBG Allocation? Telamon plans to use the funds to continue the existing Project PRIDE program. To provide support to program participants in becoming more self-sufficient. Available support includes financial literacy workshops and counseling, assistance with education and employment goals, and case management to help participant overcome obstacles to better employment and further their education. Project PRIDE Personal Responsibility in Daily Endeavors Program Year 2021-2022 Overview  Project PRIDE focuses on assisting low-income individuals with achieving self- sufficiency.  The program offers employment, training, and support resources.  Low-income families and/or individuals whose income is at or below the 125% of the current federal poverty guideline may be eligible for Project PRIDE services.  Services are available to the residents of Caswell, Person and Rockingham Counties. Challenges Addressed  Lack of access to full-time employment and jobs with benefits  Educational barriers, especially those concerning earning a high school diploma or its equivalent  Financial barriers to accessing short-term training programs through postsecondary institutions  Limited levels of employment skills and job readiness  Limited access to supportive services to help meet identified goals 61 January 18, 2022 19 Services Offered Education Employment Support Referrals HS-GED Completion Work Experience Transportation Housing Vocational Assessments Career Exploration Tuition assistance Mental Health & Substance Abuse Occupational Skills Training (hard skills) Employment Counseling Assistance with purchase of books Domestic Violence Work Skills Training (soft skills) Job Referrals Assistance with purchase of uniforms/tools Food security Financial Literacy Linkages with NC Works Career Centers Childcare Health Commissioner Gentry asked Ms. Franks how many eligible families does Telamon currently serve and how many are proposed in the program year 2022-2023 to which Ms. Franks stated Telamon currently serves 20 families with plans to reach up to 32 families as well as have an on-site staff part-time at the community college location. Ms. Franks noted goals for each family is customized based on the need(s), i.e., childcare, educational support, with an individual employment plan. A motion was made by Commissioner Gentry to and carried 5-0 to approve the Community Services Block Grant Application funding to continue Project PRIDE for program year 2022-2023, as presented. 62 January 18, 2022 20 WEBSITE REDESIGN UPDATE: IT Director, Chris Puryear provided a website redesign updated noting staff have been working diligently with the website vendor for the last three (3) months. The first step was to gather information via vendor-conducted surveys of website users and other stakeholders, a heat map study, and user testing. The survey indicated that most people use smartphones to access the website and only do so when looking for specific information. They also indicated that they would like to see clearer language and less information overall. The heat map indicated that the “employment” and “GIS” links were, by far, the most clicked links on the homepage followed by the search feature. The user testing showed that users not familiar with the inner-workings of county government have difficulty completing tasks such as finding the requirements for a marriage license and overall difficulty navigating the website. Mr. Puryear stated the designers were able to address the requests and needs indicated by the citizens and other website users in the new website design. The new layout features more user-friendly menu titles, a service finder to quickly locate services, and a fully integrated search feature. The designers also incorporated more relevant “call to action” buttons along the bottom of the main image on the homepage for easier access to regularly requested information. Mr. Puryear said staff are continuing to work with the vendor for minor adjustments and are on schedule for delivery of the final product in April of 2022. 63 January 18, 2022 21 APPOINTMENTS TO BOARDS AND COMMITTEES: Clerk to the Board, Brenda Reaves presented interested citizen applications for current vacancies received in response to an ad published in the local newspaper and on the county website. Ms. Reaves recommended the Board nominate for appointment as deemed appropriate. The Board of Commissioners and committee liaisons are encouraged to recruit citizens to fill current vacancies. Adult Care Home Community Advisory Committee 1-Year Initial Term; 3-Year Reappointment: 2 positions available Airport Commission 3-Year Term: 1 at-large position available 1) Norman Carden III requested appointment 2) Henry Newell, Jr. requested reappointment A motion was made by Commissioner Puryear and carried 5-0 to reappoint Henry Newell, Jr. to the Airport Commission for a 3-year term. Board of Health 1 position for an engineer for an unexpired term to June 30, 2023 (no applications) Environmental Issues Advisory Committee 3-Year Term: 1 position for a citizen residing in each of the following townships: Bushy Fork: 1) Larry Williams requested appointment Cunningham for an unexpired term to June 30, 2022: (no applications) Holloway: (no applications) Mt. Tirzah: (no applications) Woodsdale: 1) Joe Hodges requested appointment A motion was made by Commissioner Gentry and carried 5-0 to appoint Larry Williams (Bushy Fork representative), and Joe Hodges (Woodsdale representative) to the Environmental Issues Advisory Committee, each for a 3-year term. 64 January 18, 2022 22 Juvenile Crime Prevention Council 1-Year Initial Term: 2-Year Reappointment 1 position available for a citizen under the age of 18: (no applications) 1 position available for a citizen under the age of 18 serving on the State Youth Council: (no applications) 2-Year Term: 1 position for the Chief of Police or designee: Ricky Hughes requested reappointment 1 position for the Sheriff or designee: Aron Lappin requested appointment 1 position for the School Superintendent or designee: (no applications) 1 position for the District Attorney or designee: Alisa Black requested reappointment 1 position for the Social Services Director or designee: Ashley Stone requested reappointment 1 position for the Chief District Court Judge or designee: (no applications) 1 position available for a Juvenile Defense Attorney: (no applications) 1 designated seat for a representative for Parks & Recreation: John Hill requested reappointment up to 5 citizens-at-large: Louise Wright-Oliver requested reappointment A motion was made by Vice Chairman Sims and carried 5-0 to appoint Aron Lappin (Sheriff designee), and reappoint Ricky Hughes (Chief of Police designee), Alisa Black (District Attorney designee), Ashley Stone (Social Services’ Director designee), John Hill (Parks & Recreation representative) and Louise Wright-Oliver (citizen-at-large) to the Juvenile Crime Prevention Council, each for a 2-year term. Kerr Tar Regional Council of Government Board 1 citizen-at-large alternate position representing the private sector business (no applications) Nursing Home Advisory Committee 1-Year Initial Term: 3-Year Reappointment; 4 positions available (no applications) 65 January 18, 2022 23 Person Area Transportation System Board 3-Year Term: 1 position available for an occupational affiliation representative of the following: Health Department: Kimberly Nichols requested appointment Social Services: (no applications) Medical related entity:(no applications) private industry: Cindy Chandler requested appointment citizen-at-large: (no applications) A motion was made by Commissioner Gentry and carried 5-0 to appoint Kimberly Nichols (Health Dept. representative) and Cindy Chandler (private industry) to the Person Area Transportation System Board each for a 3-year term. Region K Aging Advisory 3-Year Term: 5 positions available (no applications) Tourism Development Authority 3-Year Term: 1 position available 1) Sally Humphries requested reappointment A motion was made by Commissioner Puryear and carried 5-0 to reappoint Sally Humphries to the Tourism Development Authority for a 3-year term. Workforce Development Board 1-Year Initial Term; 2-Year Reappointment 1 position available for a member or an officer of organized labor (no applications) 1 position available for a small business representative (no applications) 66 January 18, 2022 24 AMENDMENT TO THE RESOLUTION ESTABLISHING 2022 SCHEDULE OF REGULAR MEETINGS FOR THE BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS: County Manager, Heidi York noted the Board of Commissioners took action to set its regular schedule of meetings for 2022 at its November 15, 2021 meeting. Since that time, the NC Supreme Court moved the March 8, 2022 Primary to May 17, 2022. Due to this recent change, and the fact that the Person County Office Building Auditorium serves as a One-Stop site and an official polling site, the Board of Commissioners will need to change the location of its May 2, 2022 meeting to its Boardroom 215. Also due to this recent change, the Auditorium is now available for the Board of Commissioners’ to hold its March 7, 2022 meeting in the auditorium. As retreat planning is underway, the Board has the option to hold its annual retreat either in the FEMA Shelter Room as was adopted in November or to change the location to be held in the Kirby Upstairs Main Hall, should this location be preferred. Clerk to the Board, Brenda Reaves asked the Board to consider the changes as presented and take action to adopt an Amended Resolution Establishing 2022 Schedule of Regular Meetings so to cause copy of such to be distributed and posted. A motion was made by Commissioner Gentry and carried 5-0 to amend the Board’s Resolution establishing 2022 Schedule of Regular Meetings to reflect that the Board’s May 2, 2022 meeting will be held in the Boardroom 215, the Board’s March 7, 2022 meeting will be held in the Auditorium and the Board’s Annual Retreat, scheduled for February 22, 2022 will be held in the Kirby Upstairs Main Hall located at 213 North Main Street, Roxboro, NC and to cause copy of such amendment to be distributed and posted. 67 January 18, 2022 25 68 January 18, 2022 26 69 January 18, 2022 27 NUISANCE ORDINANCE DISCUSSION: Planning Director, Lori Oakley informed the Board that the Ordinance Regulating Automobile Graveyards and Junkyards in Person County (“Junkyard Ordinance”) was originally adopted on September 21, 1987 and re-adopted on April 6, 2015. In September 2021, Ms. Oakley stated staff updated the Board on the existing on-going violation on the Yarboro property and requested guidance as to how the Board would like for staff to proceed with the Junkyard Ordinance. Ms. Oakley noted at that time, two possible violations existed on the Yarboro property and they have since been remedied. As of December 2021, Ms. Oakley further noted the Yarboro property was in compliance with both the Junkyard Ordinance and the Planning Ordinance. Ms. Oakley said the Board previously expressed an interest in possibly amending the Junkyard Ordinance and including an amortization schedule as well as directed staff to explore other avenues of enforcement. Staff discussed the issue with County Attorney’s law partner, Kevin Hornik, who suggested implementing a nuisance ordinance. Staff feels that the nuisance ordinance might be the best avenue to enforce junk-like violations while still allowing individuals who have brought their property into compliance over the years to still be in compliance. Ms. Oakley said Mr. Hornik stated that his law firm could also draft the nuisance ordinance for Person County. Ms. Oakley requested Board consideration to direct staff on how the Board would like to proceed in this matter. Options include: 1) A possible text amendment of the Junkyard Ordinance to include an amortization schedule 2) A new nuisance ordinance 3) To leave the current Junkyard Ordinance as it is currently written and do not draft a nuisance ordinance It was the consensus of the Board through discussion that a new nuisance ordinance would address and resolve issues for the general public’s health and safety purposes. A motion was made by Commissioner Gentry and carried 5-0 to request the Brough Law Firm to draft a new nuisance ordinance with staff’s assistance for the Board’s consideration. 70 January 18, 2022 28 HUMAN RESOURCES SOFTWARE PROPOSAL: County Manager, Heidi York stated Person County was in need of upgrading its human resources technology. Ms. York said the current software vendor, NeoGov, which supports job applications, postings, and tracking of applicants, has offered the County several needed enhancements and upgrades with additional modules, which would be considered in the upcoming FY23 proposed budget. However, NeoGov was substantially increasing their pricing after the first of this year. Ms. York noted that staff worked creatively to obtain the significant savings over the next three years, and wanted to bring this opportunity to the Board for consideration in an effort to be the best stewards of taxpayer dollars. Through the informal bid process under G.S. 143-131, as suggested by the County Attorney, several potential vendors were invited to submit proposals, but none were able to meet our needs. Should the Board wish to make this investment, it would require a mid-year budget appropriation and pre-audited agreement for commitment of funds. Should the Board not desire to authorize this purchase of software at this time, there is a 60-day out clause in the proposed agreement with no penalty. Human Resources Director, Miranda Harrison provided an overview of the modules that staff are considering include:  Perform – This is a performance management platform that allows for competencies and goals to be tracked throughout the year with automatic reminders and the ability for employees and supervisors to engage with the system by adding periodic notes at pre-set check-in times.  eForms – This function allows for electronic fillable forms that we can run reports off of (examples include PAFs, teleworking agreements, volunteer leave, shared leave, parental leave, safety/injury forms, requisitions, orientation forms, etc). The system allows electronic approval routing along with reminders to be set up. While things like this up can be set up in Munis, everything must be entered manually from a paper form and there are no reminders (you have to log-in to see what needs your approval); eForms in NeoGov can be exported so the information can be imported into Munis rather than manually entered.  Learn – This platform allows us to access hundreds of training courses on a variety of topics. We currently have access to a portion of this platform for courses related to safety and risk management through our risk management pool. If we add the full Learn module it will include more courses and will allow us to integrate with the Perform platform (so we can track courses through individual development plans).  Onboard – This is a portal where employees can be assigned onboarding actions from HR or other departments with associated due dates (or exit actions – this can be used for onboarding and off-boarding). It has areas to upload videos or checklists and can be customized to brand the onboarding experience specific to Person County. It can be available for employees prior to their start date, all the way up to their first year anniversary, with pre-established checklist activities for certain times throughout their first year on the job. 71 January 18, 2022 29  Single Sign On (SSO) – This allows everyone to have one log-in for all the different NeoGov modules. The single sign-on enhances the user experience and also cuts down on admin time resetting passwords.  NHI – This is a set-up fee that is required. It is the part of the implementation process where we would ensure everything in NeoGov can be integrated with Munis (this is most important for things like PAFs) so that we don’t have to do double entry. Prioritizing the options, Ms. Harrison said the county could gain the most value from the eForms and Perform modules. NHI is also a vital component. The Learn and Onboard modules also align well to future goals. Below are the pricing options and the amounts due per year of a 3-year contract. End of Year Discount Perform, Eforms, SSO, NHI 10% off prorated term + 50% off year 1+ 50% off setup/training 600ees Annual Setup/Training Cost 12/31/2021- 6/29/2022 $19,484.17 $7,500.00 6/30/2022- 6/29/2023 $21,828.50 6/30/2023-6/29/2024 $43,657.00 Total $92,469.67 Savings $31,743.86 End of Year Discount Perform, Eforms, Learn, SSO, NHI 70% off year 1, 30% off year 2 + 50% off setup/training 600ees Annual Setup/Training Cost 12/31/2021-6/29/2022 $29,160.98 $10,500.00 6/30/2022- 6/29/2023 $17,676.10 6/30/2023-6/29/2024 $41,244.00 6/30/2024 - 6/29/2025 $58,920.00 Total $157,501.08 Savings $66,818.36 72 January 18, 2022 30 End of Year Discount Perform, Eforms, Onboard, SSO, NHI 70% off year 1, 30% off year 2 + 50% off setup/training 600ees Annual Setup/Training Cost 12/31/2021-6/29/2022 $27,838.36 $9,500.00 6/30/2022- 6/29/2023 $16,935.00 6/30/2023-6/29/2024 $39,515.00 6/30/2024 - 6/29/2025 $56,450.00 Total $150,238.36 Savings $66,471.88 End of Year Discount Perform, Eforms, Learn, Onboard, SSO, NHI 70% off year 1, 30% off year 2, 10% off year 3 + 50% off setup/training 600ees Annual Setup/Training Cost 12/31/2021-6/29/2022 $35,469.86 $12,500.00 6/30/2022- 6/29/2023 $21,514.00 6/30/2023-6/29/2024 $50,199.10 6/30/2024 - 6/29/2025 $64,541.70 Total $184,224.66 Savings $88,906.08 WITHOUT DISCOUNTS, after the first of the year, below are the per module/per year pricing (the above quotes include each of the modules listed in their respective headlines). Standard 2022 Individual Product Pricing NEOGOV Standard 2022 Prices 600 employees Annual One Time -Setup/Training Cost Onboard $12,803.23 $4,000.00 Perform $21,948.54 $6,000.00 Eforms $18,285.14 $4,000.00 Learn (upgrade from Riskpool account) $15,263.00 $3,000.00 Single Sign On $1,550.78 $2,000.00 NHI (Munis) $1,900.95 $3,000.00 73 January 18, 2022 31 Ms. York stated should the Board wish to direct staff to move forward, an appropriation from Fund Balance would be required to be approved by budget amendment. Ms. York said the County may have an opportunity to reimburse these funds back to Fund Balance if the Finance Director finds that the County is eligible to use American Rescue funding. County Attorney, Ellis Hankins noted staff worked to lock in pricing for significant savings during the holiday period with the December 31 deadline; he added the County Manager had authority to execute contracts with limitations, therefore he recommended a contract to lock in the lowest pricing with a 60-day provision for the Board of Commissioners to approve, or if not approved, there was no cost or obligation on the County’s part. A motion was made by Commissioner Gentry and carried 5-0 to accept the proposal as presented by staff. Mr. Hankins noted the next steps would be for the Board to approve a budget amendment to appropriate the funds and formalize the contract with the necessary pre-auditing by the Finance Director. 74 January 18, 2022 32 CRIMINAL HISTORY RECORD CHECK ORDINANCE REPEAL/REPLACE: Human Resources Director, Miranda Harrison presented a Criminal History Record Check Ordinance to the Board for consideration to repeal and replace for a more efficient government. Ms. Harrison said Person County Government regularly conducts criminal history record checks through North Carolina State Bureau of Investigation, Division of Criminal Information Network (SBI/DCI) as part of the County’s pre-employment screening process. The Criminal History Record Check Ordinance was adopted May 4, 2009 to allow Person County Government to utilize the SBI/DCI Network for this purpose. Ms. Harrison stated added language in the proposed Criminal History Record Check Ordinance would allow Person County Government the option to establish vendor partnerships with alternative criminal history record check providers beyond SBI/DCI. She said having vendor options is an essential need for Person County to ensure efficiency within our pre-employment screening process. Historically, the time to receive results through SBI/DCI was two weeks or less. Recently, the results have begun to take 4-6 weeks or more, significantly delaying new employee start dates. Ms. Harrison noted other industry leading vendors offer criminal history record check services with a turnaround time of less than one week for results. The proposed new language requires the Board’s adoption at its First Reading by unanimous vote or the proposed language would require a Second Reading at the Board’s next regular scheduled meeting at which time a majority vote is required for adoption. Ms. Harrison requested the Board to repeal the Criminal History Record Check Ordinance adopted May 4, 2009 and adopt the Criminal History Record Check Ordinance as presented. A motion was made by Commissioner Puryear and carried 5-0 to repeal the Criminal History Record Check Ordinance adopted May 4, 2009 and adopt the Criminal History Record Check Ordinance with the proposed new language, as presented. 75 January 18, 2022 33 76 January 18, 2022 34 77 January 18, 2022 35 CHAIRMAN’S REPORT: Chairman Powell reported that Cardinal Innovations and Vaya Health have now merged effective January 1, 2022; he added the transition was going very well and applauded Cardinal Innovations’ recent donation of Chromebooks to area schools: Roxboro Community School (80 units), Roxboro Christian Academy (40 units) and Bethel Hill (75 units.) Chairman Powell voiced ongoing concerns related to the lack of service by CenturyLink in Person County. County Manager, Heidi York and Assistant County Manager, Katherine Cathey shared in the Chairman’s frustration noting the County’s contact at CenturyLink was no longer valid and they would try to obtain new contact information to share. Commissioner Gentry shared her method to file an online complaint with the FCC and asked if the IT staff could provide a link on the County website for citizens. MANAGER’S REPORT: County Manager, Heidi York reported the Board would hear at its next meeting an update on the recent broadband study. COMMISSIONER REPORT/COMMENTS: Vice Chairman Sims reported positive news where Roxboro Savings Bank’s donation with the City of Roxboro would complete the Roxboro Pocket Park and that a ribbon cutting for the Palace Pointe new ownership was held on January 14, 2022. Chairman Powell added that was good economic news that Palace Pointe was sold to a private entity, which had opened up for business shortly thereafter. Commissioner Gentry said she had recently obtained satellite internet which was working out great. She noted she would be attending an IAIA meeting soon with a report to the Board thereafter. There were no reports from Commissioners Puryear and Palmer. Clerk to the Board, Brenda Reaves announced the Roxboro Area Chamber of Commerce notified the County that they were rescheduling the Awards Banquet from January 20th to February 3rd due to the impending weather at the Tunnel Creek property. 78 January 18, 2022 36 ADJOURNMENT: A motion was made by Commissioner Puryear and carried 5-0 to adjourn the meeting at 11:19am. _____________________________ ______________________________ Brenda B. Reaves Gordon Powell Clerk to the Board Chairman (Draft Board minutes are subject to Board approval). 79 2/7/2022 Dept./Acct No.Department Name Amount Incr / (Decr) EXPENDITURES General Fund General Government 70,060 Public Safety 16,456 Culture and Recreation (1,184) Human Services 17,570 REVENUES General Fund Other Revenues 17,130 Intergovernmental Revenues 9,884 Charges for Services 2,888 Transfer from Component Unit 73,000 Explanation: BUDGET AMENDMENT Recognizing excess revenue received from ABC Profits and bottle taxes ($73,000); received funds from vendor for recycled phones in the IT Department ($60); receipt of insurance funds for Sheriff Department's vehicle repair ($1,000); utilizing additional officer contract funds received from the ABC Board for vehicle capital in the Sheriff's Department ($2,888); receipt of American Recovery Funds for EMS ($11,068); received insurance funds for EMS vehicle repair ($1,500); recognizing small reduction in the State's grant for the Public Library (-$1,184); applying insurance proceeds received for the purchase of a replacement vehicle in DSS ($14,570); and using available funds (-$46,512) in the CIP Fund to cover the first year's acquisition and maintenance costs of software for Human Resources that was approved by the Board of Commissioners in the meeting on 1/18/22 ($46,512). BA-1280 AGENDA ABSTRACT Meeting Date: February 7, 2022 Agenda Title: Person County Health Department Fee Request Summary of Information: The Person County Health Department’s proposed new fee is associated with COVID- 19 vaccinations. The proposed fee is for the administration of the COVID-19 Pfizer pediatric third dose vaccination for ages 5-11 and will be utilized to submit claims to insurance companies in an attempt to cover the cost of the vaccine administration. The proposed new fee will allow PCHD to bill the administration fee for the COVID-19 Pfizer pediatric third dose vaccination. Individuals will not be charged a fee. Medical providers are not allowed to bill for the vaccine as it is provided by the federal government. The Board of Health approved the Fee Schedule Amendment on Monday, January 24, 2022, and in accordance with the North Carolina General Statute 130A-39(g), the Board of Health requests the approval of the Board of Commissioners to implement the proposed fees which are attached. Recommended Action: Approve recommended fee. Submitted By: Janet Clayton, Health Director 81 Description CPT Code Medicaid Rate Proposed Updated Notes Immunization administration of COVID- 19 vaccine-Pfizer pediatric 3rd dose for ages 5-11 0073A 40.00$ 50.00$ Charge is consistent with current admin fee. 82 AGENDA ABSTRACT Meeting Date: February 7, 2022 Agenda Title: Consultancy Agreement for Professional Services with Economic Leadership, LLC Summary of Information: The current EDC strategic plan will end in 2022. Most grant programs related to economic development require an existing plan, and it takes months to do the necessary analyses to draft a new plan. Since the EDC anticipates applying for relevant grant opportunities and needs a new guiding document later this year, the EDC voted unanimously at the January 25th planning session to request authorization from the Board of Commissioners for the County Manager to enter into contract with Economic Leadership, LLC, an experienced and reputable economic development consultancy firm, on behalf of the EDC. The full proposal is attached, and in addition to the Strategic Plan will also include a workforce analysis that will assist in marketing and recruitment. All deliverables are due by May 31, 2022, and there are ample existing funds in the ED budget to cover the cost. Recommended Action: Authorize the County Manager to sign the appended proposal from Economic Leadership, LLC. Submitted By: Sherry Wilborn, Economic Development Director 83 1 | P a g e Consultancy Agreement between Person County Economic Development and Economic Leadership LLC January 15, 2022 This serves as a proposed Consultancy Agreement between the Person County Economic Development and Economic Leadership LLC of Shallotte, NC for services described below. The scope of work will be performed for Person County Economic Development, (hereinafter referred to as the Client) by Ted Abernathy, Managing Partner of Economic Leadership LLC, and other supportive staff (hereinafter referred to as the Consultant.) The Consultant agrees to complete the scope of work for the Client as described below. The project will take approximately four and a half months and be completed for a budget of $37,000 for all work specified, inclusive of all materials and travel expenses. A specific timetable will be mutually agreed upon by the parties, with work beginning on or about February 7, 2022. Plan Deliverables The Person County Economic Development project will include: • A comprehensive review of all existing economic development strategies (local, regional and state). • Development of an in-depth economic assessment of Person County that will shed light on the County’s current economic reality, the impact of emerging global trends, new economic changes from COVID-19 and a rigorous review of the quantitative data for the County. o A qualitative overview of the existing information on major employers, area assets, available real estate including the mega site and regional trends and competitiveness. This review will compare the performance of the County with state and national averages. This overview will include important economic development metrics such as job growth, total earnings, location quotients, top occupations, establishments, and population growth of the overall study region. o We will then dive deeper into the County’s economy by tracking performance of specific industries and traded clusters, using materials recently completed for RTRP. o Additionally, we will identify emerging sectors and suggest future target industries. • Creation of a Comprehensive Labor Shed Workforce Supply Assessment o Defining the Person County Labor Shed ▪ Labor Shed Employment by Zip Code (Data & Maps) 84 2 | P a g e ▪ Regional Growth Patterns 2009-2019 & 2019-2021 (COVID) and Projections for 2021-2031 o Summary of Potential Business Sources of Labor ▪ Regional Commuting Patterns ▪ Wage Comparisons Across the Labor Shed ▪ Employment by Industry and Occupation ▪ Occupational Growth and Location Quotient Charts o Labor Demographic Overview ▪ Educational Attainment ▪ Age with Projections ▪ Local College Graduates ▪ Top Program Completions ▪ Unemployment Data • The Economic and Labor Shed Assessments will be supplemented by interviews and focus groups. This will add local activities and recent direction. It also adds engagement, buy-in and ownership. The Client will be responsible for identifying area leaders and stakeholders for interviews, focus groups and surveys. o Up to 8 individual interviews with elected and appointed officials and private stakeholders o Up to three business focus groups o An on-line electronic survey of board members to gather current opinions and suggestions • The development of a short (approximately 10-12 pages) assessment of trends impacting Person County’s economic competitiveness in the coming years. • An organizational capacity assessment with recommendations for future capacity and focus. • An assessment of the County’s current incentive policy with future recommendations based on best-practice research. • Finally, our report will provide a SWOT Analysis, opportunities to diversify the county economy, future challenges, and growth opportunities. The final product will be a multi- year strategic action agenda and matrix with responsibilities, timelines, expectations (metrics), and costs. • A final presentation to all stakeholders will be provided, determined by the Client. • Additional or revised deliverables may be added if the scope and costs are agreed upon by both parties. Approach to Strategic Planning An economic development strategic plan answers three basic questions: what is Person County’s current economic situation, what do local stakeholders want the county’s future to be, 85 3 | P a g e and what actions can the community and Person Economic Development realistically take to move Person County from where it is to where it aspires to be. Successful economic development plans are influenced by specific new realities: ▪ Identifying and achieving a differentiated competitive advantage, the economic development goal of all successful places, requires a combination of factors. These include the depth of workforce talent; the business climate, including costs and regulatory issues; both solid physical infrastructure and the connective infrastructure; shovel-ready sites, and buildings ready to go; and the quality-of-life factors that appeal to talented workers and engaged residents. ▪ Overwhelming global trends such as rapid urbanization, evolving globalization and ubiquitous automation and robotics are rewriting the economic landscape. Regional and local work, education, innovation, health, retail and employment hubs, can create economic transformation for a much broader region, but they also must continuously compete as both capital and labor become more mobile. ▪ Coordination, leadership, and a focus on Return-On-Investment is the key differentiator between places that succeed and those that decline. Successful efforts must have aligned leadership, clear objectives, realistic expectations, sufficient resources and talented staff to succeed. Phase One of our strategic process is the information stage, where we establish a common, agreed upon, current reality the region. We will use a combination of global competitiveness trends, recent business investment criteria and economic development delivery best practice research to establish the Client’s current competitive position. Our approach begins with three filtering criteria: ▪ Compass - the vision, mission and values Person County has already established, including its expectations for economic development. ▪ Context – Person County’s current and potential strengths and weaknesses, compared to the competition, and given those realities, what is a realistic course of action. This is information that is researched and developed by the Consultant. Finally, ▪ Change - the group of factors outside the Person County’s control that will change competitiveness soon and create the parameters of what is realistically achievable. This is information provided by Consultant and can be used by the Client during both the planning and implementation phases of the project. During phase one, we will analyze and summarize data from multiple sources. Competitiveness comparisons that establish the strengths and weaknesses of the County, a broader trend analysis of business investment decision criteria (including workforce, infrastructure, business climate, demographics, cluster or sector growth) and near-future anticipated changes that could impact future competitiveness will be examined. Stakeholders will be engaged where appropriate. 86 4 | P a g e Phase Two will reaffirm the desired and expected economic future for the Client and develop specific goals, objectives and actions to move the place from its current economic and competitive position to where it wants to be in three to ten years. Actions that will be detailed over the first three years will establish a foundation for success over a longer 10 to 20-year economic horizon. The Economic Leadership team will work with Person County Economic Development to evaluate potential actions based on four factors: control, impact, resources, and time. By incorporating these four factors we can better ensure that the actions recommended are possible and that the outcomes are achievable. Finally, Phase Three is the action stage and this is where many economic development strategic planning processes fail. Without the capacity and structure to act, no plan is achievable. The Consultant will develop the framework for delivery of services to improve the odds of successful implementation. Economic Leadership’s Community Competitiveness Model Materials - The Consultant will provide needed material as appropriate related to facilitated sessions. The Consultant will provide an electronic copy of the final report and such files that the Client may reproduce the report as needed. 87 5 | P a g e Travel - Travel costs are included in the proposal cost. Facilities - For mutually agreed upon meetings and facilitated sessions, the Client will provide facilities and will support the arrangement of the meetings. Termination of this Agreement - If the Client decides to terminate the program prior to completion, the Client will notify the Consultant immediately. Upon notification of the Client’s early termination, Consultant will deliver an invoice to Client requesting reimbursement for any costs incurred for the project to that date. Confidentiality – The Consultant agrees to keep confidential all information relating to the business of the Client. Project Completion - The project will be completed on or about May 31, 2022 but may be extended upon mutual agreement of the Client and the Consultant. Payment of Costs - The Client will pay fees of $37,000 based on agreed upon schedule. The designated contact person for the Client is: Sherry Wilborn, Economic Development Director, Person County North Carolina and the designated contact at the Economic Leadership LLC is: Ted Abernathy, Managing Partner. IN WITNESS THEREOF, the parties hereto have caused this Memorandum of Agreement to be signed by their respective officers duly authorized as of the date and year written. Date: _____________ By________________________ Heidi York, Manager Person County Government Date: January 15, 2022 By________________________ Ted Abernathy, Managing Partner, Economic Leadership LLC 88 AGENDA ABSTRACT Meeting Date: February 7, 2022 Agenda Title: Report of Unpaid Taxes Summary of Information: G.S. 105-369(a) requires that Tax Collector report to the Board the amount of unpaid 2021 taxes that are a lien on real property during the first meeting in February. This is simply a checkpoint for the Board as to the progress that the Tax Office is making on collections and a way to alert the Board if collections are down. We don’t see any issues with making the budgeted collection rate of 97.5%, however there is 1 large bankruptcy in the amount of $291,597 that will affect the final collection rate by .66% if this remains unpaid. As of January 28, 2022, our collection rate was 94.63 %, with unpaid county taxes for tax year 2021 of $1,881,466.66. Recommended Action: Accept the report. No motion needed. Submitted By: Russell Jones, Tax Administrator 89 AGENDA ABSTRACT Meeting Date: February 7, 2022 Agenda Title: Tax Office requests Order to Set Advertisement of Unpaid Real Estate Taxes to March 3, 2022 Summary of Information: A motion is required to order the advertisement and set the advertisement date for delinquent 2021 real property taxes. The Tax Office requests the order to advertise be set to March 3, 2022. The newspaper advertisement is required under G.S. 105-369(c) and can be placed anytime between March 1st and June 30th. This is a great collection tool and the sooner we advertise, the better our ending collection rate will be. The cost of the advertisement is charged to the delinquent real estate bills. Recommended Action: A motion set the Advertisement date for March 3, 2022, if appropriate. Submitted By: Russell Jones, Tax Administrator 90 AGENDA ABSTRACT Meeting Date: February 7, 2022 Agenda Title: Tax Adjustments for February 2022 Summary of Information: Attached please find the tax releases and motor vehicle pending refunds: 1. February 2022 tax releases. 2. February 2022 North Carolina Vehicle Tax System (NCVTS) pending refunds. Recommended Action: Motion to accept reports and authorize refunds. Submitted By: Russell Jones, Tax Administrator 91 NAME BILL NUMBER OPER DATE/TIME DISTRICT VALUE AMOUNT 67203301 2021-2292 DY: RP:A4E 3 RH 11/4/2021 2:20:41 PM ALLEN DREW THOMAS APPRAISER ADJUSTED BUILDING C ADVLTAX 38,244.00 275.36 APPRAISER ADJUSTED BUILDING FIREADVLTAX 38,244.00 10.52 CORRECT DECK/PORCH CRDI TOTAL RELEASES:285.88 6439305 2021-12023 DY:0RP:6 9 RH 11/5/2021 11:18:24 AM COBB GERALD W APPRAISER ADJUSTED LAND C ADVLTAX 39,750.00 286.20 APPRAISER ADJUSTED LAND CI50ADVLTAX 39,750.00 258.38 REMOVE LAND ADJ TOTAL RELEASES:544.58 2078305 2021-21635 DY:0RP:A109 87 MP 11/15/2021 10:22:53 AM BASS DOROTHY H LIFE ESTATE EXEMPTION ADDED C ADVLTAX 101,195.00 728.60 EXEMPTION ADDED FIREADVLTAX 101,195.00 27.83 ELDERLY EXEMPTION ADDED - LATE APPLICATION TOTAL RELEASES:756.43 26985301 2021-6100 DY:0RP:A65A 83 MP 11/15/2021 10:34:48 AM BURGESS ANTHONY EXEMPTION ADDED C ADVLTAX 45,000.00 324.00 EXEMPTION ADDED FIREADVLTAX 45,000.00 12.38 DVET EXEMPTION ADDED - LATE APPLICATION TOTAL RELEASES:336.38 5912301 2021-8786 DY:0RP:112 24 MP 11/15/2021 11:07:57 AM CLAYTON BRENDA A EXEMPTION ADDED C ADVLTAX 54,927.00 395.47 EXEMPTION ADDED FIREADVLTAX 54,927.00 15.10 ELDERLY EXEMPTION ADDED - LATE APPLICATION TOTAL RELEASES:410.57 12200301 2021-10131 DY:0RP:103 2B MP 11/15/2021 11:34:55 AM COUSIN TESSIE P EXEMPTION ADDED C ADVLTAX 47,250.00 340.20 EXEMPTION ADDED FIREADVLTAX 47,250.00 12.99 ELDERLY EXEMPTION ADDED - LATE APPLICATION TOTAL RELEASES:353.19 4019302 2021-4158 DY:0RP:A85 16 MP 11/15/2021 1:44:21 PM DAY DOROTHY D BLALOCK EXEMPTION ADDED C ADVLTAX 44,674.00 321.65 EXEMPTION ADDED FIREADVLTAX 44,674.00 12.29 ELDERLY EXEMPTION ADDED - LATE APPLICATION TOTAL RELEASES:333.94 5514301 2021-10673 DY:0RP:16 40 1 MP 11/15/2021 3:09:54 PM FEATHERSTONE DELIAH A EXEMPTION ADDED C ADVLTAX 31,887.00 229.59 EXEMPTION ADDED CI50ADVLTAX 31,887.00 207.27 ELDERLY EXEMPTION ADDED - LATE APPLICATION TOTAL RELEASES:436.86 66205201 2021-33847 DY: PERSONAL PROPERTY MP 11/15/2021 3:34:20 PM JUNE SYLVIA EXEMPTION ADDED C ADVLTAX 8,105.00 58.36 EXEMPTION ADDED C PEN FEE 8,105.00 5.84 RUN DATE: 1/31/2022 9:03 AM RELEASES REPORT Person County 92 NAME BILL NUMBER OPER DATE/TIME DISTRICT VALUE AMOUNT EXEMPTION ADDED CI50ADVLTAX 8,105.00 52.68 EXEMPTION ADDED CI50PEN FEE 8,105.00 5.27 ELDERLY EXEMPTION ADDED - LATE APPLICATION TOTAL RELEASES:122.15 9450302 2021-8200 DY:0RP:A70 70 MP 11/15/2021 4:09:06 PM MCCANN DOROTHIE EXEMPTION ADDED C ADVLTAX 69,673.00 501.65 EXEMPTION ADDED FIREADVLTAX 69,673.00 19.16 ELDERLY EXEMPTION ADDED - LATE APPLICATION TOTAL RELEASES:520.81 50713301 2021-26370 DY:0RP:A78 256 MP 11/15/2021 4:26:24 PM STREET NANCY A EXEMPTION ADDED C ADVLTAX 25,000.00 180.00 EXEMPTION ADDED FIREADVLTAX 25,000.00 6.88 ELDERLY EXEMPTION ADDED - LATE APPLICATION TOTAL RELEASES:186.88 7571301 2021-151 DY:0RP:A58 22B MP 11/15/2021 4:35:51 PM MITCHELL FRED THOMAS EXEMPTION ADDED C ADVLTAX 45,000.00 324.00 EXEMPTION ADDED FIREADVLTAX 45,000.00 12.38 DVET EXEMPTION ADDED - LATE APPLICATION TOTAL RELEASES:336.38 720301 2021-7150 DY:0RP:A40 60 MP 11/16/2021 10:32:37 AM NELSON THELMA T EXEMPTION ADDED C ADVLTAX 61,258.00 441.06 EXEMPTION ADDED FIREADVLTAX 61,258.00 16.85 ELDERLY EXEMPTION ADDED- LATE APPLICATION TOTAL RELEASES:457.91 68228301 2021-2822 DY:0RP:A68 22 MP 11/16/2021 10:41:54 AM PERRY ROBERT EXEMPTION ADDED C ADVLTAX 45,000.00 324.00 EXEMPTION ADDED FIREADVLTAX 45,000.00 12.38 DVET EXEMPTION ADDED - LATE APPLICATION TOTAL RELEASES:336.38 7865301 2021-8418 DY:0RP:A82 9A MP 11/16/2021 10:53:08 AM RICE JAMES A EXEMPTION ADDED C ADVLTAX 25,000.00 180.00 EXEMPTION ADDED FIREADVLTAX 25,000.00 6.88 ELDERLY EXEMPTION ADDED - LATE APPLICATION TOTAL RELEASES:186.88 71135301 2021-28844 DY:0RP:102 164 MP 11/16/2021 11:20:24 AM RILEY REBECCA EXEMPTION ADDED C ADVLTAX 115,809.00 833.82 EXEMPTION ADDED CI50ADVLTAX 115,809.00 752.76 ELDERLY EXEMPTION ADDED - LATE APPLICATION TOTAL RELEASES:1,586.58 668302 2021-17465 DY:0RP:A13 79 MP 11/16/2021 11:26:29 AM PLENTY LARRY EXEMPTION ADDED C ADVLTAX 48,615.00 350.03 RUN DATE: 1/31/2022 9:03 AM RELEASES REPORT Person County 93 NAME BILL NUMBER OPER DATE/TIME DISTRICT VALUE AMOUNT EXEMPTION ADDED FIREADVLTAX 48,615.00 13.37 ELDERLY EXEMPTION ADDED - LATE APPLICATION TOTAL RELEASES:363.40 1843301 2021-6114 DY:0RP:A64 89B MP 11/16/2021 11:35:20 AM OAKLEY KATHLEEN EXEMPTION ADDED C ADVLTAX 42,476.00 305.83 EXEMPTION ADDED FIREADVLTAX 42,476.00 11.68 ELDERLY EXEMPTION ADDED - LATE APPLICATION TOTAL RELEASES:317.51 1904303 2021-24734 DY:0RP:A63 247 MP 11/16/2021 1:19:50 PM MOORE JUDY ANN EXEMPTION ADDED C ADVLTAX 25,000.00 180.00 EXEMPTION ADDED FIREADVLTAX 25,000.00 6.88 ELDERLY EXEMPTION ADDED - LATE APPLICATION TOTAL RELEASES:186.88 2199301 2021-3011 DY:0RP:A68 16 MP 11/16/2021 2:25:57 PM TINGEN JAMES CHRISTOPHER EXEMPTION ADDED C ADVLTAX 23,687.00 170.55 EXEMPTION ADDED FIREADVLTAX 23,687.00 6.51 DVET EXEMPTION ADDED - LATE APPLICATION TOTAL RELEASES:177.06 29968301 2021-8682 DY:0RP:A69 81 MP 11/16/2021 2:43:31 PM WILLIAMS SHAWN PHILIP EXEMPTION ADDED C ADVLTAX 43,324.00 311.93 EXEMPTION ADDED FIREADVLTAX 43,324.00 11.91 ELDERLY EXEMPTION ADDED - LATE APPLICATION TOTAL RELEASES:323.84 26065302 2021-22604 DY: RP:69 170 MP 11/16/2021 2:53:07 PM WILSON DANNY RAY EXEMPTION ADDED C ADVLTAX 25,000.00 180.00 EXEMPTION ADDED FIREADVLTAX 25,000.00 6.88 ELDERLY EXEMPTION ADDED - LATE APPLICATION TOTAL RELEASES:186.88 18907301 2021-1473 DY: RP:A24A 35 MP 11/16/2021 3:02:38 PM YOUNG OTIS RANDOLPH ESTATE EXEMPTION ADDED C ADVLTAX 238,511.00 1,717.28 EXEMPTION ADDED FIREADVLTAX 238,511.00 65.59 ELDERLY EXEMPTION ADDED - LATE APPLICATION TOTAL RELEASES:1,782.87 9828301 2021-1974 DY:0RP:A34 48 MP 11/16/2021 3:11:49 PM SMITH BETTY H LIFE ESTATE EXEMPTION ADDED C ADVLTAX 49,313.00 355.05 EXEMPTION ADDED FIREADVLTAX 49,313.00 13.56 ELDERLY EXEMPTION ADDED - LATE APPLICATION TOTAL RELEASES:368.61 21298302 2021-7627 DY: RP:A84 18 MP 11/16/2021 3:21:28 PM KELLEY ROSEMARIE EXEMPTION ADDED C ADVLTAX 56,098.00 403.91 RUN DATE: 1/31/2022 9:03 AM RELEASES REPORT Person County 94 NAME BILL NUMBER OPER DATE/TIME DISTRICT VALUE AMOUNT EXEMPTION ADDED FIREADVLTAX 56,098.00 15.43 ELDERLY EXEMPTION ADDED - LATE APPLICATION TOTAL RELEASES:419.34 70508301 2021-19244 DY:0RP:A80 206 MP 11/16/2021 3:22:20 PM DAVIS DORIS CLAYTON EXEMPTION ADDED C ADVLTAX 45,000.00 324.00 EXEMPTION ADDED FIREADVLTAX 45,000.00 12.38 DVET EXEMPTION ADDED - LATE APPLICATION TOTAL RELEASES:336.38 56836101 2021-16167 DY:0RP:50 2 MP 11/16/2021 3:58:48 PM REFORMATION CHRISTIAN CHURCH EXEMPTION ADDED C ADVLTAX 357,873.00 2,576.69 EXEMPTION ADDED CI50ADVLTAX 357,873.00 2,326.17 EXEMPTION ADDED - LATE APPLICATION TOTAL RELEASES:4,902.86 56836101 2021-15820 DY:0RP:50 3 MP 11/16/2021 3:59:55 PM REFORMATION CHRISTIAN CHURCH EXEMPTION ADDED C ADVLTAX 19,440.00 139.97 EXEMPTION ADDED CI50ADVLTAX 19,440.00 126.36 EXEMPTION ADDED - LATE APPLICATION TOTAL RELEASES:266.33 37106201 2021-200875 DY:21 PERSONAL PROPERTY MP 11/17/2021 4:01:59 PM ALLEN LAURIN BROOKS LISTING ADJUSTED PERSONAL PROPERTY C ADVLTAX 13,740.00 98.93 LISTING ADJUSTED PERSONAL PROPERTY FIREADVLTAX 13,740.00 3.78 billed incorrectly TOTAL RELEASES:102.71 8042201 2021-40059 DY: PERSONAL PROPERTY RH 11/22/2021 4:46:22 PM PLESANT HENRY N JR LISTING ADJUSTED PERSONAL PROPERTY C ADVLTAX 8,910.00 64.15 LISTING ADJUSTED PERSONAL PROPERTY C PEN FEE 8,910.00 6.42 LISTING ADJUSTED PERSONAL PROPERTY FIREADVLTAX 8,910.00 2.45 LISTING ADJUSTED PERSONAL PROPERTY FIREPEN FEE 8,910.00 0.25 BOAT SOLD 2 YEARS AGO TOTAL RELEASES:73.27 45300303 2021-3320 DY: RP:A39 38 SRJ 11/24/2021 10:58:03 AM HOLEMAN CALVIN WILSON JR APPRAISER ADJUSTED LAND C ADVLTAX 3,410.00 24.55 APPRAISER ADJUSTED LAND FIREADVLTAX 3,410.00 0.94 OVER CHARGE ON ACREAGE TOTAL RELEASES:25.49 45300303 2020-3320 DY: RP:A39 38 SRJ 11/24/2021 11:00:39 AM HOLEMAN CALVIN WILSON JR APPRAISER ADJUSTED LAND C ADVLTAX 3,126.00 22.51 APPRAISER ADJUSTED LAND FIREADVLTAX 3,126.00 0.86 CORRECTION IN ACREAGE TOTAL RELEASES:23.37 45300303 2019-3320 DY: RP:A39 38 SRJ 11/24/2021 11:02:44 AM HOLEMAN CALVIN WILSON JR APPRAISER ADJUSTED LAND C ADVLTAX 3,126.00 22.82 APPRAISER ADJUSTED LAND FIREADVLTAX 3,126.00 0.86 CORRECTION IN ACREAGE TOTAL RELEASES:23.68 RUN DATE: 1/31/2022 9:03 AM RELEASES REPORT Person County 95 NAME BILL NUMBER OPER DATE/TIME DISTRICT VALUE AMOUNT 45300303 2018-3320 DY: RP:A39 38 SRJ 11/24/2021 11:04:42 AM HOLEMAN CALVIN WILSON JR APPRAISER ADJUSTED LAND C ADVLTAX 3,126.00 21.88 APPRAISER ADJUSTED LAND FIREADVLTAX 3,126.00 0.31 CORRECTION IN ACREAGE TOTAL RELEASES:22.19 45300303 2017-3320 DY: RP:A39 38 SRJ 11/24/2021 11:06:38 AM HOLEMAN CALVIN WILSON JR APPRAISER ADJUSTED LAND C ADVLTAX 3,126.00 21.88 CORRECTION IN ACREAGE TOTAL RELEASES:21.88 45300116 2016-1151266 DY: RP:A39 38 SRJ 11/24/2021 11:08:34 AM HOLEMAN CALVIN WILSON JR APPRAISER ADJUSTED LAND C ADVLTAX 3,126.00 21.88 CORRECTION IN ACREAGE TOTAL RELEASES:21.88 68220101 2020-38315 DY: PERSONAL PROPERTY RH 12/7/2021 3:36:39 PM LAWSONS TRANSPORT LLC LISTING ADJUSTED PERSONAL PROPERTY C ADVLTAX 59,708.00 429.90 LISTING ADJUSTED PERSONAL PROPERTY C PEN FEE 59,708.00 42.99 LISTING ADJUSTED PERSONAL PROPERTY FIREADVLTAX 59,708.00 16.42 LISTING ADJUSTED PERSONAL PROPERTY FIREPEN FEE 59,708.00 1.64 VEH NT IN PERSON COUNTY TOTAL RELEASES:490.95 12382305 2021-5314 DY: RP:A42 28 MP 12/10/2021 3:47:46 PM HATFIELD ANNE LOUISE DAY APPRAISER ADJUSTED LAND C ADVLTAX 44,958.00 323.70 APPRAISER ADJUSTED LAND FIREADVLTAX 44,958.00 12.36 OVERCHARGED BY 9.71 ACS F/2021 TOTAL RELEASES:336.06 9537202 2021-37497 DY: PERSONAL PROPERTY MP 12/14/2021 11:15:30 AM CORONA JOSE FERNANDO TRINIDAD LISTING ADJUSTED PERSONAL PROPERTY C ADVLTAX 2,306.00 16.60 LISTING ADJUSTED PERSONAL PROPERTY CI50ADVLTAX 2,306.00 14.99 SWMH BURNED IN 2020 TOTAL RELEASES:31.59 67153201 2018-38055 DY: PERSONAL PROPERTY MP 12/15/2021 9:26:23 AM ANDERSON JAMES FREDERICK LISTING ADJUSTED PERSONAL PROPERTY C ADVLTAX 6,610.00 46.27 LISTING ADJUSTED PERSONAL PROPERTY C PEN FEE 6,610.00 4.63 LISTING ADJUSTED PERSONAL PROPERTY CI50ADVLTAX 6,610.00 44.29 LISTING ADJUSTED PERSONAL PROPERTY CI50PEN FEE 6,610.00 4.43 LISTING ADJUSTED PERSONAL PROPERTY C GARNFEE 6,610.00 30.00 BOAT IN ARIZONA TOTAL RELEASES:129.62 67153201 2019-38055 DY: PERSONAL PROPERTY MP 12/15/2021 9:27:03 AM ANDERSON JAMES FREDERICK LISTING ADJUSTED PERSONAL PROPERTY C ADVLTAX 6,179.00 45.11 LISTING ADJUSTED PERSONAL PROPERTY C PEN FEE 6,179.00 4.51 LISTING ADJUSTED PERSONAL PROPERTY CI50ADVLTAX 6,179.00 41.40 LISTING ADJUSTED PERSONAL PROPERTY CI50PEN FEE 6,179.00 4.14 BOAT IN ARIZONA TOTAL RELEASES:95.16 67153201 2020-38055 DY: PERSONAL PROPERTY MP 12/15/2021 9:27:36 AM ANDERSON JAMES FREDERICK LISTING ADJUSTED PERSONAL PROPERTY C ADVLTAX 5,875.00 42.30 RUN DATE: 1/31/2022 9:03 AM RELEASES REPORT Person County 96 NAME BILL NUMBER OPER DATE/TIME DISTRICT VALUE AMOUNT LISTING ADJUSTED PERSONAL PROPERTY C PEN FEE 5,875.00 4.23 LISTING ADJUSTED PERSONAL PROPERTY CI50ADVLTAX 5,875.00 39.36 LISTING ADJUSTED PERSONAL PROPERTY CI50PEN FEE 5,875.00 3.94 BOAT IN ARIZONA TOTAL RELEASES:89.83 67153201 2021-38055 DY: PERSONAL PROPERTY MP 12/15/2021 9:28:01 AM ANDERSON JAMES FREDERICK LISTING ADJUSTED PERSONAL PROPERTY C ADVLTAX 5,667.00 40.80 LISTING ADJUSTED PERSONAL PROPERTY C PEN FEE 5,667.00 4.08 LISTING ADJUSTED PERSONAL PROPERTY CI50ADVLTAX 5,667.00 36.84 LISTING ADJUSTED PERSONAL PROPERTY CI50PEN FEE 5,667.00 3.68 BOAT IN ARIZONA TOTAL RELEASES:85.40 1207305 2021-10822 DY:0RP:89 10F MP 12/16/2021 2:35:56 PM GARRETT GARY DEAN APPRAISER ADJUSTED BUILDING C ADVLTAX 69,468.00 500.17 APPRAISER ADJUSTED BUILDING FIREADVLTAX 69,468.00 19.10 DWMH SOLD 12/5/20 PER DMV - H0NC05534772AB - MOVED TO A31-31 TOTAL RELEASES:519.27 67835101 2021-10990 DY:0RP:107 78 SRJ 12/22/2021 1:44:40 PM DLH DEVELOPMENT LLC APPRAISER ADJUSTED LAND C ADVLTAX 9,382.00 67.55 APPRAISER ADJUSTED LAND CI50ADVLTAX 9,382.00 60.98 LAND SIZE SHOULD BE .09 INSTEAD OF .36/COMMON AREA TOTAL RELEASES:128.53 71226101 2021-41602 DY: PERSONAL PROPERTY RH 12/29/2021 9:31:58 AM WM COMPACTOR SOLUTIONS INC C PEN FEE 0.00 5.35 CI50PEN FEE 0.00 4.83 REMOVE LATE LISTING TOTAL RELEASES:10.18 69819301 2021-18764 DY: RP:A18 50 MP 12/30/2021 10:14:20 AM CLAYTON RICHARD OWEN LISTING ADJUSTED PERSONAL PROPERTY C ADVLTAX 13,255.00 95.44 LISTING ADJUSTED PERSONAL PROPERTY C PEN FEE 13,255.00 9.54 LISTING ADJUSTED PERSONAL PROPERTY FIREADVLTAX 13,255.00 3.65 LISTING ADJUSTED PERSONAL PROPERTY FIREPEN FEE 13,255.00 0.37 PERSONAL ITEMS BELONG TO PREVIOUS OWNER TOTAL RELEASES:109.00 71989301 2021-300524 DY:18RP:A57 118 SRJ 12/30/2021 10:23:18 AM MOORE CHRISTOPHER APPRAISER ADJUSTED LAND C ADVLTAX 4,995.00 34.97 APPRAISER ADJUSTED LAND FIREADVLTAX 4,995.00 0.50 ROLLBACK ALREADY PROCESSED-SEE 2020 - 300335 TOTAL RELEASES:35.47 71989301 2021-300525 DY:19RP:A57 118 SRJ 12/30/2021 10:23:42 AM MOORE CHRISTOPHER APPRAISER ADJUSTED LAND C ADVLTAX 4,995.00 36.46 APPRAISER ADJUSTED LAND FIREADVLTAX 4,995.00 1.37 ROLLBACK ALREADY PROCESSED-SEE 2020 - 300335 TOTAL RELEASES:37.83 RUN DATE: 1/31/2022 9:03 AM RELEASES REPORT Person County 97 NAME BILL NUMBER OPER DATE/TIME DISTRICT VALUE AMOUNT 71989301 2021-300526 DY:20RP:A57 118 SRJ 12/30/2021 10:24:08 AM MOORE CHRISTOPHER APPRAISER ADJUSTED LAND C ADVLTAX 4,995.00 35.96 APPRAISER ADJUSTED LAND FIREADVLTAX 4,995.00 1.37 ROLLBACK ALREADY PROCESSED-SEE 2020 - 300335 TOTAL RELEASES:37.33 71989301 2021-300527 DY:21RP:A57 118 SRJ 12/30/2021 10:24:34 AM MOORE CHRISTOPHER APPRAISER ADJUSTED LAND C ADVLTAX 6,704.00 48.27 APPRAISER ADJUSTED LAND FIREADVLTAX 6,704.00 1.84 ROLLBACK ALREADY PROCESSED-SEE 2020 - 300335 TOTAL RELEASES:50.11 45782301 2021-2090 DY: RP:A13 73 SRJ 12/30/2021 12:38:02 PM KLICK NORMAN F JR LISTING ADJUSTED PERSONAL PROPERTY C ADVLTAX 19,302.00 138.97 LISTING ADJUSTED PERSONAL PROPERTY C PEN FEE 19,302.00 13.90 LISTING ADJUSTED PERSONAL PROPERTY FIREADVLTAX 19,302.00 5.31 LISTING ADJUSTED PERSONAL PROPERTY FIREPEN FEE 19,302.00 0.53 2007 COBALT SOLD 09/02/2020 PER BILL OF SALE TOTAL RELEASES:158.71 63655201 2021-39813 DY: PERSONAL PROPERTY SRJ 1/5/2022 2:20:09 PM GEARY PAUL M LISTING ADJUSTED PERSONAL PROPERTY C ADVLTAX 500.00 3.60 LISTING ADJUSTED PERSONAL PROPERTY C PEN FEE 500.00 0.36 LISTING ADJUSTED PERSONAL PROPERTY FIREADVLTAX 500.00 0.14 LISTING ADJUSTED PERSONAL PROPERTY FIREPEN FEE 500.00 0.01 BOAT LISTED IN DURHAM TOTAL RELEASES:4.11 202150687900 2021-506879 DY:20 PERSONAL PROPERTY MP 1/14/2022 2:56:10 PM PERKINS WILLIAM GARY LISTING ADJUSTED PERSONAL PROPERTY C ADVLTAX 23,800.00 71.40 LISTING ADJUSTED PERSONAL PROPERTY FIREADVLTAX 23,800.00 2.73 NO GAP TOTAL RELEASES:74.13 20455302 2021-12027 DY:0RP:6 15 SRJ 1/19/2022 9:22:11 AM NEWCOMB TERESA DAWN APPRAISER ADJUSTED BUILDING C ADVLTAX 1,500.00 10.80 APPRAISER ADJUSTED BUILDING CI50ADVLTAX 1,500.00 9.75 STORAGE BUILDING REMOVED TOTAL RELEASES:20.55 20455302 2020-12027 DY:0RP:6 15 SRJ 1/19/2022 9:24:42 AM NEWCOMB TERESA DAWN APPRAISER ADJUSTED BUILDING C ADVLTAX 1,500.00 10.80 APPRAISER ADJUSTED BUILDING CI50ADVLTAX 1,500.00 10.05 STORAGE BUIDLING REMOVED TOTAL RELEASES:20.85 20455302 2019-12027 DY:0RP:6 15 SRJ 1/19/2022 9:27:50 AM NEWCOMB TERESA DAWN APPRAISER ADJUSTED BUILDING C ADVLTAX 1,500.00 10.95 APPRAISER ADJUSTED BUILDING CI50ADVLTAX 1,500.00 10.05 STORAGE BUILDING REMOVED TOTAL RELEASES:21.00 RUN DATE: 1/31/2022 9:03 AM RELEASES REPORT Person County 98 NAME BILL NUMBER OPER DATE/TIME DISTRICT VALUE AMOUNT 20455302 2018-12027 DY:0RP:6 15 SRJ 1/19/2022 9:35:34 AM NEWCOMB TERESA DAWN APPRAISER ADJUSTED BUILDING C ADVLTAX 1,500.00 10.50 APPRAISER ADJUSTED BUILDING CI50ADVLTAX 1,500.00 10.05 STORAGE BUILDING REMOVED TOTAL RELEASES:20.55 20455302 2017-12027 DY: RP:6 15 SRJ 1/19/2022 9:38:39 AM DICKERSON TERESA DAWN APPRAISER ADJUSTED BUILDING C ADVLTAX 1,500.00 10.50 APPRAISER ADJUSTED BUILDING CI50ADVLTAX 1,500.00 10.05 STORAGE BUILDING REMOVED TOTAL RELEASES:20.55 20455116 2016-1159436 DY: RP:6 15 SRJ 1/19/2022 9:41:23 AM DICKERSON TERESA DAWN APPRAISER ADJUSTED BUILDING C ADVLTAX 1,500.00 10.50 APPRAISER ADJUSTED BUILDING CI50ADVLTAX 1,500.00 10.05 STORAGE BUILDING REMOVED TOTAL RELEASES:20.55 69697301 2021-28124 DY:0RP:A76 186 RH 1/20/2022 10:16:47 AM BRUNK KEVIN S APPRAISER ADJUSTED LAND C ADVLTAX 68,210.00 491.11 APPRAISER ADJUSTED LAND SW30FFEEFEE 68,210.00 20.00 APPRAISER ADJUSTED LAND FIREADVLTAX 68,210.00 18.76 DELETE LAND DOUBLE BILLED TOTAL RELEASES:529.87 39527303 2021-28949 DY: PERSONAL PROPERTY RH 1/20/2022 11:53:06 AM CLEMENTSFIELD FARM LLC LISTING ADJUSTED PERSONAL PROPERTY C ADVLTAX 2,139.00 15.40 LISTING ADJUSTED PERSONAL PROPERTY FIREADVLTAX 2,139.00 0.59 NOT OWNER OF TRLR TOTAL RELEASES:15.99 54529201 2021-38885 DY: PERSONAL PROPERTY MP 1/20/2022 3:37:22 PM ELLIOTT LARRY LEE LISTING ADJUSTED PERSONAL PROPERTY C ADVLTAX 921.00 6.63 LISTING ADJUSTED PERSONAL PROPERTY C PEN FEE 921.00 0.66 LISTING ADJUSTED PERSONAL PROPERTY FIREADVLTAX 921.00 0.25 LISTING ADJUSTED PERSONAL PROPERTY FIREPEN FEE 921.00 0.03 MOVED OUT OF STATE - SEPT 2020 TOTAL RELEASES:7.57 65252201 2019-40321 DY: PERSONAL PROPERTY MP 1/20/2022 4:00:18 PM JACKSON MARVIN WAYNE LISTING ADJUSTED PERSONAL PROPERTY C ADVLTAX 9,645.00 70.41 LISTING ADJUSTED PERSONAL PROPERTY C PEN FEE 9,645.00 7.04 LISTING ADJUSTED PERSONAL PROPERTY FIREADVLTAX 9,645.00 2.65 LISTING ADJUSTED PERSONAL PROPERTY FIREPEN FEE 9,645.00 0.27 LISTING ADJUSTED PERSONAL PROPERTY C GARNFEE 9,645.00 30.00 BOAT REGISTRATION EXPIRED 7/31/2018 TOTAL RELEASES:110.37 67784201 2021-34873 DY: PERSONAL PROPERTY MP 1/27/2022 4:46:04 PM CTM HOMES LLC LISTING ADJUSTED PERSONAL PROPERTY C ADVLTAX 2,022.00 14.56 LISTING ADJUSTED PERSONAL PROPERTY CI50ADVLTAX 2,022.00 13.14 SWMH SOLD TO BABARA RIDLEY IN JULY 2020 TOTAL RELEASES:27.70 RUN DATE: 1/31/2022 9:03 AM RELEASES REPORT Person County 99 NAME BILL NUMBER OPER DATE/TIME DISTRICT VALUE AMOUNT 24008112 2012-45030 MOTOR VEHICLE: N SITUS: /2012 MP 1/28/2022 4:02:31 PM HOLDER KEVIN LAWRENCE LISTING ADJUSTED PERSONAL PROPERTY C ADVLTAX 15,650.00 109.55 MILITARY TOTAL RELEASES:109.55 NET RELEASES PRINTED:20,486.61 TOTAL TAXES RELEASED 20,486.61 RUN DATE: 1/31/2022 9:03 AM RELEASES REPORT Person County 100 C ADVLTAX - County Tax TAX YEAR RATE YEAR REAL VALUE RELEASED PERS VALUE RELEASED TOTAL VALUE RELEASED REAL TAX RELEASED PERS TAX RELEASED MV VALUE RELEASED MV TAXES RELEASED TOTAL VALUE RELEASED TOTAL TAXES RELEASED 2012 2012 0 0 0 0.00 0.00 15,650 109.55 15,650 109.55 2016 2016 4,626 0 4,626 32.38 0.00 0 0.00 4,626 32.38 2017 2017 4,626 0 4,626 32.38 0.00 0 0.00 4,626 32.38 2018 2018 4,626 6,610 11,236 32.38 46.27 0 0.00 11,236 78.65 2019 2019 4,626 15,824 20,450 33.77 115.52 0 0.00 20,450 149.29 2020 2020 4,626 65,583 70,209 33.31 472.20 0 0.00 70,209 505.51 2021 2018 4,995 0 4,995 34.97 0.00 0 0.00 4,995 34.97 2021 2019 4,995 0 4,995 36.46 0.00 0 0.00 4,995 36.46 2021 2020 4,995 23,800 28,795 35.96 71.40 0 0.00 28,795 107.36 2021 2021 1,967,636 76,867 2,044,503 14,166.99 553.44 0 0.00 2,044,503 14,720.43 DIST TOTAL 2,005,751 188,684 2,194,435 14,438.60 1,258.83 15,650 109.55 2,210,085 15,806.98 C GARNFEE - GARNISHMENT FEE TAX YEAR RATE YEAR REAL VALUE RELEASED PERS VALUE RELEASED TOTAL VALUE RELEASED REAL TAX RELEASED PERS TAX RELEASED MV VALUE RELEASED MV TAXES RELEASED TOTAL VALUE RELEASED TOTAL TAXES RELEASED 2018 2018 0 6,610 6,610 0.00 30.00 0 0.00 6,610 30.00 2019 2019 0 9,645 9,645 0.00 30.00 0 0.00 9,645 30.00 DIST TOTAL 0 16,255 16,255 0.00 60.00 0 0.00 16,255 60.00 C PEN FEE - County Late List TAX YEAR RATE YEAR REAL VALUE RELEASED PERS VALUE RELEASED TOTAL VALUE RELEASED REAL TAX RELEASED PERS TAX RELEASED MV VALUE RELEASED MV TAXES RELEASED TOTAL VALUE RELEASED TOTAL TAXES RELEASED 2018 2018 0 6,610 6,610 0.00 4.63 0 0.00 6,610 4.63 2019 2019 0 15,824 15,824 0.00 11.55 0 0.00 15,824 11.55 2020 2020 0 65,583 65,583 0.00 47.22 0 0.00 65,583 47.22 2021 2021 0 56,660 56,660 0.00 46.15 0 0.00 56,660 46.15 DIST TOTAL 0 144,677 144,677 0.00 109.55 0 0.00 144,677 109.55 CI50ADVLTAX - City of Roxboro TAX YEAR RATE YEAR REAL VALUE RELEASED PERS VALUE RELEASED TOTAL VALUE RELEASED REAL TAX RELEASED PERS TAX RELEASED MV VALUE RELEASED MV TAXES RELEASED TOTAL VALUE RELEASED TOTAL TAXES RELEASED 2016 2016 1,500 0 1,500 10.05 0.00 0 0.00 1,500 10.05 2017 2017 1,500 0 1,500 10.05 0.00 0 0.00 1,500 10.05 2018 2018 1,500 6,610 8,110 10.05 44.29 0 0.00 8,110 54.34 2019 2019 1,500 6,179 7,679 10.05 41.40 0 0.00 7,679 51.45 2020 2020 1,500 5,875 7,375 10.05 39.36 0 0.00 7,375 49.41 2021 2021 575,641 18,100 593,741 3,741.67 117.65 0 0.00 593,741 3,859.32 DIST TOTAL 583,141 36,764 619,905 3,791.92 242.70 0 0.00 619,905 4,034.62 CI50PEN FEE - CI50PEN FEE TAX YEAR RATE YEAR REAL VALUE RELEASED PERS VALUE RELEASED TOTAL VALUE RELEASED REAL TAX RELEASED PERS TAX RELEASED MV VALUE RELEASED MV TAXES RELEASED TOTAL VALUE RELEASED TOTAL TAXES RELEASED 2018 2018 0 6,610 6,610 0.00 4.43 0 0.00 6,610 4.43 2019 2019 0 6,179 6,179 0.00 4.14 0 0.00 6,179 4.14 2020 2020 0 5,875 5,875 0.00 3.94 0 0.00 5,875 3.94 2021 2021 0 13,772 13,772 0.00 13.78 0 0.00 13,772 13.78 DIST TOTAL 0 32,436 32,436 0.00 26.29 0 0.00 32,436 26.29 FIREADVLTAX - Fire District Tax TAX YEAR RATE YEAR REAL VALUE RELEASED PERS VALUE RELEASED TOTAL VALUE RELEASED REAL TAX RELEASED PERS TAX RELEASED MV VALUE RELEASED MV TAXES RELEASED TOTAL VALUE RELEASED TOTAL TAXES RELEASED 2018 2018 3,126 0 3,126 0.31 0.00 0 0.00 3,126 0.31 RUN DATE: 1/31/2022 9:03 AM RELEASES REPORT Person County 101 2019 2019 3,126 9,645 12,771 0.86 2.65 0 0.00 12,771 3.51 2020 2020 3,126 59,708 62,834 0.86 16.42 0 0.00 62,834 17.28 2021 2018 4,995 0 4,995 0.50 0.00 0 0.00 4,995 0.50 2021 2019 4,995 0 4,995 1.37 0.00 0 0.00 4,995 1.37 2021 2020 4,995 23,800 28,795 1.37 2.73 0 0.00 28,795 4.10 2021 2021 1,391,995 58,767 1,450,762 382.83 16.17 0 0.00 1,450,762 399.00 DIST TOTAL 1,416,358 151,920 1,568,278 388.10 37.97 0 0.00 1,568,278 426.07 FIREPEN FEE - Fire LateList TAX YEAR RATE YEAR REAL VALUE RELEASED PERS VALUE RELEASED TOTAL VALUE RELEASED REAL TAX RELEASED PERS TAX RELEASED MV VALUE RELEASED MV TAXES RELEASED TOTAL VALUE RELEASED TOTAL TAXES RELEASED 2019 2019 0 9,645 9,645 0.00 0.27 0 0.00 9,645 0.27 2020 2020 0 59,708 59,708 0.00 1.64 0 0.00 59,708 1.64 2021 2021 0 42,888 42,888 0.00 1.19 0 0.00 42,888 1.19 DIST TOTAL 0 112,241 112,241 0.00 3.10 0 0.00 112,241 3.10 SW30FFEEFEE - Stormwater TAX YEAR RATE YEAR REAL VALUE RELEASED PERS VALUE RELEASED TOTAL VALUE RELEASED REAL TAX RELEASED PERS TAX RELEASED MV VALUE RELEASED MV TAXES RELEASED TOTAL VALUE RELEASED TOTAL TAXES RELEASED 2021 2021 68,210 0 68,210 20.00 0.00 0 0.00 68,210 20.00 DIST TOTAL 68,210 0 68,210 20.00 0.00 0 0.00 68,210 20.00 GRAND TOTALS:4,073,460 682,977 4,756,437 18,638.62 1,738.44 15,650 109.55 4,772,087 20,486.61 RUN DATE: 1/31/2022 9:03 AM RELEASES REPORT Person County 102 Payee Name Address 3 Refund Type Refund Reason Create Date Tax Jurisdiction Levy Type Total Change 01 Tax ($167.58) 60 Tax ($6.40) $173.98 01 Tax ($40.12) 60 Tax ($1.53) $41.65 01 Tax ($71.46) 60 Tax ($2.73) $74.19 01 Tax ($36.75) 60 Tax ($1.40) $38.15 01 Tax ($54.22) 60 Tax ($2.07) $56.29 01 Tax ($166.32) 60 Tax ($6.35) $172.67 01 Tax ($120.45) 60 Tax ($4.60) $125.05 01 Tax ($39.21) 50 Tax ($36.49) 50 Vehicle Fee $0.00 $75.70 01 Tax ($43.56) 60 Tax ($1.66) $45.22 01 Tax ($13.82) 60 Tax ($0.52) $14.34 01 Tax ($30.90) 60 Tax ($1.18) $32.08 ADCOCK, AUSTIN JARED Vehicle Sold 11/29/2021 ROXBORO, NC 27574 Proration COOK, JEFFREY KEITH ROXBORO, NC 27574 Proration Vehicle Sold 11/15/2021 CRUMPTON, JAMES SLADE JR WILMINGTON, NC 28405 Proration Vehicle Sold 12/14/2021 FARA, MARTY JAY TIMBERLAKE, NC 27583 Proration Vehicle Totalled 12/13/2021 GARRETT, EARL THOMAS ROUGEMONT, NC 27572 Proration Vehicle Sold 12/07/2021 GENTRY, LARRY WAYNE ROXBORO, NC 27574 Proration Vehicle Sold 11/30/2021 HONEYCUTT, CHRISTIE SINK TIMBERLAKE, NC 27583 Proration Vehicle Sold 11/01/2021 JAY, KENNETH NOEL ROXBORO, NC 27573 Proration Vehicle Sold 11/10/2021 KRAUSE, JAMES ROGER JR ROXBORO, NC 27574 Adjustment < $100 Over Assessment 12/13/2021 LEA, REBECCA CLAYTON ROXBORO, NC 27574 Proration Vehicle Sold 11/24/2021 LLERENA, CRYSTAL GAYLE ROXBORO, NC 27574 Proration Vehicle Sold 12/16/2021 103 Payee Name Address 3 Refund Type Refund Reason Create Date Tax Jurisdiction Levy Type Total Change 01 Tax ($26.53) 60 Tax ($1.02) $27.55 01 Tax ($16.23) 50 Tax ($14.65) 50 Vehicle Fee $0.00 $30.88 OVERPAYMENT ($159.66) $159.66 01 Tax ($9.00) 60 Tax ($0.34) $9.34 01 Tax $0.00 50 Tax ($37.12) 50 Vehicle Fee ($20.00) 60 Tax $1.57 $55.55 01 Tax ($130.32) 60 Tax ($4.97) $135.29 01 Tax ($11.68) 60 Tax ($0.45) $12.13 01 Tax ($132.28) 60 Tax ($5.05) $137.33 01 Tax ($34.50) 50 Tax ($32.11) 50 Vehicle Fee $0.00 $66.61 01 Tax ($74.08) 60 Tax ($2.83) $76.91 LUNSFORD, LARRY JUNIUS ROXBORO, NC 27574 Proration Vehicle Totalled 11/02/2021 MAJORS, PENNY LOUISE ROXBORO, NC 27573 Proration Vehicle Sold 11/18/2021 MCARTHUR, MARY SPEIGHT TIMBERLAKE, NC 27583 Overpayment Overpayment 12/10/2021 PARADIS, BUFFY MARIE ROXBORO, NC 27574 Proration Vehicle Totalled 11/10/2021 PAYLOR, TIFFANY SHIRRETT ROXBORO, NC 27573 Adjustment < $100 Situs error 11/02/2021 PORTERFIELD, SUSAN HARRIS HURDLE MILLS, NC 27541 Proration Vehicle Sold 12/29/2021 ROGERS, JOAN CONNER TIMBERLAKE, NC 27583 Proration Vehicle Sold 11/05/2021 SHERRON, MICHAEL TRAVIS HURDLE MILLS, NC 27541 Proration Vehicle Sold 11/15/2021 SMITH, JEROME ROXBORO, NC 27573 Proration Vehicle Totalled 12/08/2021 SULLIVAN, ISIAH DAKOTA TIMBERLAKE, NC 27583 Proration Vehicle Sold 12/16/2021 104 Payee Name Address 3 Refund Type Refund Reason Create Date Tax Jurisdiction Levy Type Total Change 01 Tax ($58.68) 60 Tax ($2.24) $60.92 01 Tax ($43.32) 50 Tax ($39.11) 50 Vehicle Fee $0.00 $82.43 01 Tax ($6.73) 60 Tax ($0.26) $6.99 01 Tax ($61.23) 50 Tax ($56.98) 50 Vehicle Fee $0.00 $118.21 01 Tax ($8.10) 60 Tax ($0.31) $8.41 01 Tax ($80.17) 60 Tax ($3.06) $83.23 01 Tax ($9.11) 60 Tax ($0.35) $9.46 01 Tax ($9.82) 60 Tax ($0.38) $10.20 01 Tax ($122.00) 60 Tax ($4.66) $126.66 01 Tax ($16.77) 60 Tax ($0.64) $17.41 DAVIS, RICKEY LEE HURDLE MILLS, NC 27541 Proration Vehicle Sold 01/11/2022 SULLIVAN, ISIAH DAKOTA TIMBERLAKE, NC 27583 Proration Vehicle Sold 12/16/2021 SWANN, FELICIA ANN ROXBORO, NC 27573 Proration Vehicle Sold 12/01/2021 SWANN, THEODORE LINWOOD CREEDMOOR, NC 27522 Proration Vehicle Totalled 11/08/2021 THOMAS, SAUNDRA SYKES ROXBORO, NC 27573 Proration Vehicle Sold 11/18/2021 THOMPSON, VANESSA ALEXANDRA TIMBERLAKE, NC 27583 Proration Vehicle Sold 11/02/2021 WHITLOW, JIMMY CECIL ROXBORO, NC 27573 Proration Vehicle Sold 12/02/2021 AKERS, BRENDA ROBERTS TIMBERLAKE, NC 27583 Proration Vehicle Totalled 01/25/2022 BRIAN C PARKER INVESTMENTS LLC TIMBERLAKE, NC 27583 Adjustment >= $100 Mileage 01/12/2022 WRENN, FRANCES OAKES LEASBURG, NC 27291 Proration Vehicle Sold 11/29/2021 105 Payee Name Address 3 Refund Type Refund Reason Create Date Tax Jurisdiction Levy Type Total Change 01 Tax ($69.88) 50 Tax ($63.08) 50 Vehicle Fee $0.00 $132.96 01 Tax ($14.15) 60 Tax ($0.54) $14.69 01 Tax ($55.53) 60 Tax ($2.12) $57.65 01 Tax ($55.53) 60 Tax ($2.12) $57.65 01 Tax ($55.53) 60 Tax ($2.12) $57.65 01 Tax ($18.57) 60 Tax ($0.71) $19.28 01 Tax ($103.57) 60 Tax ($3.95) $107.52 01 Tax ($12.34) 50 Tax ($11.14) 50 Vehicle Fee $0.00 $23.48 01 Tax ($10.56) 60 Tax ($0.40) $10.96 01 Tax ($2.56) 60 Tax ($0.10) $2.66 01 Tax ($55.97) 60 Tax ($2.14) $58.11 SHERRON, MICHAEL TRAVIS HURDLE MILLS, NC 27541 Proration Vehicle Sold SHERRY, HELEN MELTON ROXBORO, NC 27573 Proration Vehicle Sold 01/11/2022 01/18/2022 MILES, DEBORAH JEAN ROXBORO, NC 27573 Adjustment < $100 Mileage OVERGARD, RICHARD NEIL SR ROXBORO, NC 27574 Proration Vehicle Sold 01/07/2022 01/13/2022 GENTRY, MARGIE DICKERSON ROXBORO, NC 27573 Proration Vehicle Totalled IBARRA, MITZY SORAYA ROXBORO, NC 27574 Proration Vehicle Sold 01/25/2022 01/20/2022 FIRST CHOICE LEASING DURHAM, NC 27717 Proration Vehicle Sold FIRST CHOICE LEASING DURHAM, NC 27717 Proration Vehicle Sold 01/24/2022 01/24/2022 FIRST CHOICE LEASING DURHAM, NC 27717 Proration Vehicle Sold FIRST CHOICE LEASING DURHAM, NC 27717 Proration Vehicle Sold 01/24/2022 01/24/2022 FAULKNER, MAURICE TYRONE ROXBORO, NC 27573 Proration Vehicle Sold 01/18/2022 106 AGENDA ABSTRACT Meeting Date: February 7, 2022 Agenda Title: Fee Schedule Amendment – Transportation Summary of Information: When the FY22 Budget was adopted, Person Area Transportation System (PATS) was unsure if it would receive Rural Operating Assistance Program (ROAP) funds from the State of North Carolina. Therefore, ROAP revenues and fees were not included in the FY22 Budget. On Nov. 23, 2021, the county was awarded FY22 ROAP funds and now needs to reinstate the ROAP mileage rate. The FY21 rate was $1.40 for both general users and Elderly and Disabled Transportation Assistance Program (EDTAP) users. The proposed fee is the same amount as the FY21 approved fee. Recommended Action: Approve the reinstatement of the ROAP mileage rate in the amount of $1.40 for both general and EDTAP users. Submitted By: Katherine Cathey, Assistant County Manager 107 AGENDA ABSTRACT Meeting Date: February 7, 2022 Agenda Title: Consideration to grant or deny request to revise the Person County Solar Energy System Ordinance (Petition TA-03-21) and a Proposed Zoning Permit Fee and an Annual Inspection Fee The proposed text amendment (Petition TA-03-21) requires legislative review by the Board. The Board of Commissioners held its public hearing at its January 18, 2022 meeting and took action to take consideration of this item at its February 7, 2022 meeting. Summary of Information: On August 16, 2021, the Person County Board of Commissioners adopted a 6-month moratorium on level 3 solar energy systems (greater than 10 acres) to allow staff time to review the current requirements and make adjustments accordingly. Staff reviewed solar energy system ordinances across the state (including Beaufort County, Warren County, Stanly County, Nash County, Carteret County, Granville County and Orange County) and then drafted revisions to the ordinance. The draft ordinance was then sent to the following boards/committees for review: Economic Development Commission, Airport Commission and Farm Bureau. The following is a summary of the commentary received from the aforementioned groups: -Economic Development Committee: No suggested changes. Farm Bureau: The consensus among the board is the concern about the cleanup and removal of decommissioned solar panels and the long-term effects on the soil after removal, as well as concern of anything being left behind and not disposed of properly or not disposed of at all. They are still opposed to solar panels taking over or monopolizing productive farmland. They feel that as the nation’s population is expanding, the need for more farming would increase and they felt that solar sites could be bad for future agricultural production. -Airport Committee: No suggested changes other than updating the website for solar glare studies. Staff is proposing the following changes to the ordinance: No changes to where level 3 solar energy systems can be located (other than reformatting the Table to match the Table of Uses in the Planning Ordinance). 108  No changes to setbacks (other than reformatting the Table to match the Planning Ordinance setback table); however, a 100’ setback from a well was added.  Buffer width reduced from 150’ to 100’ while planting height of trees increases from 3’ to 6’ at the time of planting.  Aviation notification to other agencies increased from 30 days to 45 days prior to public hearing. All special use permits/conditional district rezoning application along with aviation requirements will also be submitted to the Person County Airport Commission.  Decommissioning bond amount shall be reviewed by an engineer every 5 years.  Conditional district rezoning language was added just to clarify a process that is already allowed.  Additional information shall be included with the special use permit / conditional district rezoning application including but not limited to: a copy of the lease agreement, battery storage information, a Phase 1 environmental analysis, and any other relevant studies/documents requested by staff and/or boards.  A fire response and emergency response section was added to ensure proper emergency response coverage along with the requirement of an emergency response plan that must be filed with the Fire Marshal.  Prior to receiving a Certificate of Compliance, a noise level certification letter shall be submitted.  An annual inspection shall be required by staff to ensure continued compliance. Planning Staff Recommendation: Planning Staff recommends approval of TA-03-21. The proposed text will address board member and community concerns and better regulate solar energy systems. Planning Board Recommendation: At the Planning Board meeting on December 9, 2021, the Board recommended unanimous (4-0) approval of TA-03-21 with the following changes:  Table 2.1 – Change “S” in the chart to “S/CD” to better reflect that it includes both a special use permit and conditional district rezoning.  Section 2.3 – Change the title to “Height and Size Limitation” and include a “b” that reads: o B. The maximum size of a level 3 solar energy system shall not exceed three hundred (300) acres as measured around the immediate perimeter of the panels and shall not be located within one (1) linear mile of an existing level 3 solar energy system.  Section 3.1-E.2.c – include what PFAS means in parenthesis (Polyfluoroalkyl substances). Board member James had concerns about limiting the size of a level 3 solar energy system and the impact it would have on economic development for the county. Board member George had concerns about requiring a one-mile separation in between level 3 solar energy systems and how it would affect an adjoining property owner who might want to develop a solar energy system in the future. Both board members voted to approve the text amendment as written with the Planning Board’s recommended changes in order to move it along in the process due to the time-limited moratorium. 109 At the Board of Commissioners’ January 18, 2022 meeting, there was a consensus for the following changes:  Table 2.1 was amended to prohibit level 2 and level 3 solar energy systems in the RC (Rural Conservation) zoning district.  Table 2.2 was amended to require a 200’ setback for all level 2 and level 3 solar energy systems from the property lines and/or right-of-way lines. This setback will include area for a 150’ buffer and 50’ of open area for emergency access.  Section 2.3(b) was amended to state that the maximum size of a level 3 solar energy system shall be 100 acres.  Section 2.4(b) was amended to require a 150’ vegetative buffer.  Section 2.6(d) was amended to require an engineer to review the decommissioning bond amount every 3 years. Solar energy system applications for a conditional district rezoning or special use permit already have a fee that accompany them that is comparable to other jurisdictions. Staff recommends adding a zoning permit fee for level 2 and 3 solar energy systems and an annual inspection fee for level 2 and 3 solar energy systems. Staff proposes the following fees:  Zoning permit for level 2 and 3 solar energy systems: $1,000 per megawatt with a minimum fee of $2,500 (this is the same as Nash County, NC)  Annual solar energy system inspection fee (for level 2 and 3 systems): $300 (This is the same as Stanly County, NC) Planning Staff Recommendation: Planning Staff recommends approval of the proposed fee schedule. Recommended Action: Vote to approve, approve with modifications or deny the requested text amendment and the fee schedule as proposed. The Board must also include a Statement of Reasonableness and Consistency with the motion. Statement of Reasonableness and Consistency: The text amendment request is consistent with the Person County and City of Roxboro Joint Comprehensive Land Use Plan and future planning goals and objectives of Person County. It is reasonable and in the public interest as it will provide clear regulations in the Person County Solar Energy System Ordinance. The proposed text amendment meets the Comprehensive Land Use Plan Guiding Principle 2, which states to facilitate sustainable economic growth. Submitted By: Lori Oakley, Planning Director 110 Petition TA-03-21 A request by the Person County Planning Department, on behalf of the Person County Board of Commissioners, to revise the Person County Solar Energy System Ordinance. 111 BACKGROUND INORMATION■The Person County Solar Energy System Ordinance was adopted by the Board of Commissioners on Oct. 5, 2020 following a 7-month moratorium on solar energy systems, excluding accessory solar uses for both residential and non-residential uses. ■On Aug. 16, 2021, the Person County Board of Commissioners adopted a 6-month moratorium on level 3 solar energy systems (greater than 10 acres) to allow staff time to review the current requirements and make adjustments accordingly.■Staff reviewed solar energy system ordinances across the state (Beaufort County, Warren County, Stanly County, Nash County, Carteret County, Granville County and Orange County) and then drafted revisions to the ordinance.112 CONCERNS REGARDING SOLAR ENERGY SYSTEMS■Industrial Use■Buffer height■Battery storage■Decommissioning■Size limitation■Effect on the environment & wildlife■Heat island effect■Loss of farmland113 Proposed Changes to the Solar Energy System Ordinance■No changes to where level 3 solar energy systems can be located (other than reformatting the Table to match the Table of Uses in the Planning Ordinance). The Planning Board did request that I add “CD” to the table where “S” is currently listed.■No changes to setbacks (other than reformatting the Table to match the Planning Ordinance setback table); however, a setback of 100’ from a well was added after speaking with the EH Supervisor.■Buffer width reduced from 150’ to 100’ while planting height of trees increases from 3’ to 6’ at the time of planting.■Aviation notification to other agencies increased from 30 days to 45 days prior to public hearing. All special use permits/conditional district rezoning application along with aviation requirements will also be submitted to the Person County Airport Commission in addition to staff.114 Proposed Changes to the Solar Energy System Ordinance■We currently require a decommissioning plan and a bond amount equal to 1.25 times the cost of the project. Additional language includes that the bond shall be reviewed every 5 years by an engineer. ■Conditional district rezoning language was added just to clarify a process that is already allowed.■Additional information shall be included with the special use permit / conditional district rezoning application including but not limited to: a copy of the lease agreement, battery storage information, a Phase 1 environmental analysis, and any other relevant studies/documents requested by staff and/or boards.115 Proposed Changes to the Solar Energy System Ordinance■A fire response and emergency response section was added to ensure proper emergency response coverage along with the requirement of an emergency response plan that must be filed with the Fire Marshal. Any new equipment needed by the local fire district shall be provided by the owner of the solar energy system. Chemical fire suppressants shall be stored by any battery storage areas if applicable. And the 50’ buffer around the site shall be maintained by the owner and inspected annually (see inspection below).■Prior to receiving a Certificate of Compliance, a noise level certification letter shall be submitted to ensure that the noise from any equipment is barely audible at the property boundaries.■An annual inspection shall be required by staff to ensure continued compliance. A fee will be added at a later date for that inspection. 116 Additional ReviewsThe draft ordinance was also sent to the following boards/committees for review: Economic Development Commission, Airport Commission and Farm Bureau. The following is a summary of the commentary received from the aforementioned groups:■Economic Development Committee: No suggested changes.■Farm Bureau: The consensus among the board is the concern about the cleanup and removal of decommissioned solar panels and the long-term effects on the soil after removal, as well as concern of anything being left behind and not disposed of properly or not disposed of at all. They are still opposed to solar panels taking over or monopolizing productive farmland. They feel that as the nation’s population is expanding, the need for more farming would increase and they felt that solar sites could be bad for future agricultural production.■Airport Committee: No suggested changes other than updating the website address for solar glare studies.117 CONCERNS REGARDING SOLAR ENERGY SYSTEMS■Industrial Use■Buffer height■Battery storage■Decommissioning■Size limitation■Effect on the environment & wildlife■Heat island effect■Loss of farmland118 PLANNING STAFF RECOMMENDATION■Planning Staff recommends approval of TA-03-21. The proposed text will address board member and community concerns and better regulate solar energy systems. 119 PLANNING BOARD RECOMMENDATIONAt the Planning Board meeting on December 9, 2021, the Board recommendedunanimous (4-0) approval of TA-03-21 with the following changes:■Table 2.1 – Change “S” in the chart to “S/CD” to better reflect that it includes both a special use permit and conditional district rezoning.■Section 2.3 – Change the title to “Height and Size Limitation” and include a “b” that reads:–B. The maximum size of a level 3 solar energy system shall not exceed three hundred (300) acres as measured around the immediate perimeter of the panels and shall not be located within one (1) linear mile of an existing level 3 solar energy system.■Section 3.1-E.2.c – include what PFAS means in parenthesis (Polyfluoroalkylsubstances).120 PLANNING BOARD RECOMMENDATION CONTINUED■Board member James had concerns about limiting the size of a level 3 solar energy system and the impact it would have on economic development for the county. ■Board member George had concerns about requiring a one-mile separation in between level 3 solar energy systems and how it would affect an adjoining property owner who might want to develop a solar energy system in the future. Both board members voted to approve the text amendment as written with the Planning Board’s recommended changes in order to move it along in the process due to the time-limited moratorium.121 BOC REQUESTED CHANGES TO DRAFT ORDINANCE■Table 2.1 was amended to prohibit level 2 and level 3 solar energy systems in the RC (Rural Conservation) zoning district.■Table 2.2 was amended to require a 200’ setback for all level 2 and level 3 solar energy systems from the property lines and/or right-of-way lines. This setback will include area for a 150’ buffer and 50’ of open area for emergency access.■Section 2.3(b) was amended to state that the maximum size of a level 3 solar energy system shall be 100 acres.■Section 2.4(b) was amended to require a 150’ vegetative buffer.■Section 2.6(d) was amended to require an engineer to review the decommissioning bond amount every 3 years.122 REASONABLENESS AND CONSISTENCY STATEMENT AND COMPREHENSIVE PLANThe text amendment request is consistent with the Person County and City of Roxboro Joint Comprehensive Land Use Plan and future planning goals and objectives of Person County. It is reasonable and in the public interest as it will provide clear regulations in the Person County Solar Energy System Ordinance. The proposed text amendment meets the Comprehensive Land Use Plan Guiding Principle 2, which states to facilitate sustainable economic growth. 123 124 125 126 127 128 129 130 131 132 133 134 135 136 137 138 139 140 141 142 143 144 145 146 147 148 149 150 151 152 153 154 155 156 157 158 159 160 AGENDA ABSTRACT Meeting Date: February 7, 2022 Agenda Title: Broadband Infrastructure Inventory Study Findings and Recommendations Summary of Information: At its March 1, 2021 Budget Retreat, the Board of Commissioners established improving broadband infrastructure and connectivity as a top priority for Person County. The board expressed an interest in conducting a study to assess the current status of broadband services, opportunities to improve, and strategies to extend broadband throughout the county. On March 15, 2021, the board approved a proposal by ECC Technologies, Inc. to: (a) refresh and update the 2015 telecommunications infrastructure inventory study, including an Outside Plant (OSP) study, (b) map the current status of available broadband service within the county, (c) review the county’s fiber project – its suitability and positioning to support new broadband initiatives by others, (d) review RiverStreet and State of North Carolina survey information and (e) consult with the county to review options and next steps including service provider options. The Executive Summary is attached, and the full report will be finalized prior to the board’s annual retreat. Jeff Brooks, Sr. Director – Consulting with ECC Technologies, will present the study findings and recommendations to the board. Board members may ask questions and discuss next steps. Recommended Action: Receive report and discuss next steps. Submitted By: Katherine M. Cathey, Assistant County Manager 161 Broadband Infrastructure Inventory Study for Person County, NC Executive Summary January 26, 2022 DRAFT ECC Technologies 13341 New Falls of Neuse Rd. Raleigh, NC 27614 All information included in this report is considered confidential by ECC Technologies, Inc. The information in this proposal was gathered for the exclusive use of Person County for the purposes of planning. Any other use of this information is strictly prohibited. This information is considered confidential trade secret information and includes confidential and proprietary service provider information and is not to be reproduced in any form or disclosed without the expressed written consent of ECC Technologies. 162 Person County Broadband Study – Executive Summary 2 | Page Broadband Infrastructure Inventory Study for Person County NC Executive Summary January 26, 2022 Introduction Broadband access has become one of the foundational resources allowing a community to compete and thrive in the 21st century. Broadband enables business, education, medicine, government, and public safety to perform their functions efficiently. It is a critical component of economic development and a community’s ability to attract and retain industry. Recent surveys show high-speed broadband is now as important to job creation and business locations as good transportation and skilled labor. Broadband is today considered infrastructure as critical as roads, electricity, and water. Inadequate broadband has become a barrier to community growth, competitiveness, and economic development. This has led to something called “The Digital Divide.” Person County has commissioned this study in part to understand its rural area broadband capacity, as well as explore opportunities for possible broadband expansion to help the County overcome this Digital Divide. The Digital Divide On Feb. 8, 1996, the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) created the Telecommunications Act to establish competition and facilitate growth in the telecommunications industry, which previously had been a government-regulated monopoly. Despite the success of increasing competition and encouraging innovation, a technology gap has occurred between communities with access to affordable broadband service and those without. This division is termed the “Digital Divide.” Existing Infrastructure Despite the increased need for broadband service, rural areas of the country with access to the Internet still rely largely on aging copper-based infrastructure. As a result, users may not have Internet availability, or be limited to dial-up, DSL, or satellite connections for access. Unfortunately, upgrading copper’s limited bandwidth to the high bandwidth capacity of fiber has not been an area of focus for the telecommunications industry. The incumbent providers are reluctant to invest in 163 Person County Broadband Study – Executive Summary 3 | Page expensive telecommunications infrastructure upgrades without support from grant funding as these projects do not show profitability. Efforts to Close the Digital Divide Over the past year three years, the North Carolina GREAT Grant and the FCC Regional Digital Opportunity Fund (RDOF) programs have awarded or will be awarding a total of $712,712 in Person County. The USDA ReConnect program has not provided funding for Person County as of the date of this report. In 2019, NC Wireless/River Street applied for $1.9M and was awarded, according to the NC BIO website, $560,300 for areas in Person County. As a requirement of the grant, NCW/RiverStreet added another $301,700 to the project for a total of $862,000, which will serve 392 households and 11 businesses north of Hyco Lake and north of Moriah. According to the other award reviews, Spectrum will be receiving over $75K from the FCC RDOF program to connect 933 new locations in the County in the coming years. NC GREAT Grant Under the current North Carolina budget, $1.2B will be made available for Broadband funding. Of that amount, $350M has been allocated for the next round of GREAT grant awards. The rules for the next round of GREAT grants have changed in accordance to the recently passed NC Bill 947, as discussed below. American Rescue Plan (ARP) Funding On March 11, 2021, a national $1.9 trillion COVID-19 relief package was signed into law including funds which can be used for broadband infrastructure development at state and local levels. The Interim Final Rule states eligible projects should reliably deliver minimum speeds of 100 Mbps download and 100 Mbps upload. In cases where it is impracticable due to geography, or a project is not financially feasible the speeds can be 100/20 mbps with the ablility to upgrade. Underserved areas are defined as locations which do not have wireline connections that reliably deliver at least 25 Mbps download speed and 3 Mbps of upload speed. Under this program, not all homes in designated unserved or underserved areas will be served due to the potential expense of extremely hard to serve address locations. State House Bill 947 Filed on May 11, 2021, the HB947 bill called “The GREAT Broadband Expansion Act” is legislation directed at establishing the state’s Completing Access to Broadband program and support broadband expansion through the GREAT grant program utilizing federal American Rescue Plan Act Funds. 164 Person County Broadband Study – Executive Summary 4 | Page Preceding Projects in Person County In 2014, ECC conducted a broadband study to identify the state of the telecommunications industry in the County. Based on the results of the study a number of recommendations were developed to help the County move forward with broadband initiatives. In 2016, the County developed and made public a broadband survey campaign to collect information from residents and businesses to understand areas of need. In the same year the County released an RFP to identify a service provider partner to work with to develop last mile solutions in underserved areas. An agreement with NC Wireless (now RiverStreet) resulted in an investment by the County of $250,000 in grant funds and NC Wireless matching that with an additional $275,000 to deliver last mile services via fixed wireless technology to end users. Beginning in 2017, the County began construction of a fiber backbone to connect the public safety towers and a number of county and city government and other facilities. Construction was completed in early 2021. The network consists of 52 miles of 288 strand cable at a cost of $3M. The network was “overbuilt” to allow for potential service providers and end users. Economic Development As discussed throughout this document, the majority of concern about inadequate broadband services relates to residents and small business. The lack of sufficient broadband availability also affects the local economic developer’s ability to locate and attract employers and employees. Commission of the Study In March of 2021, Person County, North Carolina, contracted with ECC Technologies, Inc. (ECC) to perform a number of tasks including mapping current broadband infrastructure to the extent possible and being prepared to consult with the County on potential next steps. The inventory component included fiber optic and coaxial cable and tower infrastructure within Person County. ECC’s Outside Plant (OSP) team drove specifically identified roads in the County and, to the extent possible, physically identified and documented the County’s existing broadband infrastructure. As per the agreed upon scope of work, ECC did not drive populated/incorporated locations as our focus was on the rural areas of the County. Summary maps are included in the full report including information about fiber optic and coaxial cabling, central office and remote terminal locations, and vertical assets. Much of the data/information has also been placed into an interactive electronic geographic information system (GIS) database which will be provided to the County. 165 Person County Broadband Study – Executive Summary 5 | Page Broadband Infrastructure Overview In the Appendix to the complete report, is a section which provides additional detail about each of these technologies. This section is expecially useful for users of this report with limited technical backgrounds. Telecommunications Service Providers in the County Voice, video, and data services are provided to County residents and businesses by a variety of companies using a range of technologies and infrastructures. Services can be provided, as previously discussed, over copper wire, coaxial cable, fiber optic cable, wireless technologies, and satellite. The incumbent telephone company, or ILEC (incumbent local exchange carrier) and the incumbent cable TV providers are the primary owners of telecommunications infrastructure within the County. There are several Competitive Local Exchange Carriers (CLECs) offering commercial services. Additionally, there are two (Wireless Internet Service Providers [WISPs]), three satellite providers, and a number of cellular companies providing access within Person County. Each of these providers use different methods of delivering services to their customers, resulting in varying speeds and reliability. Typically, fiber provides the fastest, most reliable speeds, while coax, copper wire, wireless, and satellite provide lower speeds and are less reliable. Copper wire is an older technology with limitations inherent to its structure; wireless speed and reliability are dependent on distance from the infrastructure and clear line of sight; satellite can be compromised by weather or obstacles like foliage. These factors are important to bear in mind when determining whether businesses and residents truly have adequate access to effective Internet services. Incumbent Local Exchange Carriers (ILEC) The major ILEC providing service within the County is CenturyLink, with Frontier Communications providing service in a very small area near the southern border. An ILEC is subject to certain federal and state regulatory oversight for certain services. CenturyLink CenturyLink’s territory represents over 99% of the County, including the County seat of Roxboro. The carrier has fiber routing through the area connecting to their Central Offices (COs) in the County as well as ones bordering the County. CenturyLink offers DirecTV, voice, data services, DSL, cloud services, and managed services to the businesses and residents in the County. According to its FCC 477 filing they offer DSL from 1 to 940 Mbps down and 0.25 to 940 Mbps up for both residential and business service. 166 Person County Broadband Study – Executive Summary 6 | Page Frontier Frontier is the incumbent telephone company for a very small area along the southern border of the County. Frontier has one Central Office located in Durham County that serves Person. According to its website and the FCC 477 database, Frontier can provide DSL based Internet service that ranges from 1 to 12 Mbps download and 128 Kbps to 1 Mbps upload depending on customer location, as well as phone and TV service (DISH). Competitive Local Exchange Carriers (CLEC) Competitive Local Exchange Carriers (CLECs) are telephone companies which compete with the Incumbent Local Exchange Carriers (ILECs). CLECs arose as a result of the Telecommunication Act of 1996, which was intended to promote competition among long distance and local phone service providers. The term is used to differentiate between new or potential competitors and established local exchange carriers. ECC identified two CLEC type companies with facilities in Person County: Level 3 and Windstream as facilities based providers. Level 3/CenturyLink Level 3 (acquired by CenturyLink in 2017) reported they are providing fiber-based services to non- residential customers in selected blocks in Person County. Windstream (Earthlink and Paetec) Windstream is a national CLEC that provides competitive service (CLEC) in some marketplaces. According to its FCC 477 filing report, Windstream provides copper-based and fiber service to a few non-residential customers in the Roxboro area. Cable Provider Cable providers offer their service via fiber optic or coaxial cable. Spectrum Communications (formerly Charter) is the sole cable TV provider in the County. Spectrum operates a hybrid fiber/coaxial-based network system in the County, which gives it the capability to provide dedicated business-based fiber services including ethernet, voice, video, managed services, and high bandwidth residential service over coaxial cable. According to its FCC filing, Spectrum provides residential “triple play” services of voice, Internet and cable TV at prices starting at $99 in the area. Speeds of 940Mbps are offered to both residential and business customers. Business service packages start at 200Mps and include business voice services with no contracts. Both fiber and coax can be used to provide broadband service. This is shown on the map in the full report, which shows the extent of coaxial service within the County. 167 Person County Broadband Study – Executive Summary 7 | Page Wireless Internet Service Providers (WISPs) Wireless Internet service providers (WISPs) are not cellular providers but use radio frequencies to transmit signals from a tower to a receiver at the home or business and generally rely on line-of-sight to transmit a clear signal. Most WISPs utilize unlicensed spectrum in the 5.8 ghz frequency space. This is an efficient spectrum for usage but is compromised by line of sight requirements and certain limitations on the concurrent number of users at high speeds. Most fixed wireless equipment manufacturers now represent themselves as coexisting with fiber as a component of a hybrid solution, rather than a fiber alternative or replacement. RiverStreet (NC Wireless) RiverStreet Networks is based in Wilkesboro, NC and is a subsidiary company of Wilkes Telecommunications. Wilkes is a telephone cooperative in Wilkes County, North Carolina that utilized federal grants awarded in 2009 to expand fiber based services through that county. According to its FCC 477 report, utilizing fixed wireless technology, RiverStreet provides a maximum speed of 25 Mbps down and 3 Mbps and provides service in certain areas of the County for residential and commercial users. According to its web site, slower speed (3Mbps) services start at $34 per month. Person County has been working with RiverStreet (NC Wireless) following a 2017 award from the County to expand wireless services in underserved areas. RiverStreet has further partnered with the Piedmont Electric Membership Corporation (PEMC), an ECC client, to utilize the fiber backbone owned by PEMC to assist in service expansion in the County. US Cellular US Cellular is the other fixed wireless provider identified in this study and in addition to its cellular service, offers 2 Mbps using unused cellular bandwidth, with coverage throughout most of the County. Due to its very limited bandwidth offering, US Cellular is not considered a viable broadband option in the County. Satellite Services Satellite providers use geostationary satellites orbiting the Earth to transmit signals from the Network Operations Center (NOC) to a satellite dish mounted on a business or residence. Line of sight is required. According to their 477 reports, both Hughesnet and Viasat claim 100% residential coverage into Person County. As with all satellite providers, one of the greatest issues with service is latency. This proves problematic when users are engaging in time sensitive activities, such as video conferencing or voice calls. 168 Person County Broadband Study – Executive Summary 8 | Page Cellular Service Providers There are four national cellular service providers with complete or partial coverage in Person County with varying connection speeds. The providers’ website coverage maps for AT&T Wireless, T-Mobile, Verizon Wireless and US Cellular show they provide 4G and 5G GSM and LTE coverage. Cellular providers use radio frequencies to complete phone calls, send text messages, and transmit data from the nearest cell tower to the phone in use. Cellular frequencies are licensed with fixed bands assigned by the FCC to the providers. Therefore, one provider is unable to “step on” another providers’ frequencies and impact service to their subscriber. Regional Wide Area Networks Microelectronics Center of North Carolina (MCNC) In 1985, in collaboration with the State of North Carolina, MCNC began creating the statewide North Carolina Research and Education Network (NCREN) to provide the first broadcast-quality, two-way interactive, multipoint video and audio system in the United States. Their fiber route is located through the central section of Person County routing east and west and collocating in Roxboro. This 144-strand count fiber has a number of alternative service providers on it today, including RiverStreet, Conterra, and others that provide service anywhere along the MCNC route. ECC Technologies is the sole authorized commercialization partner for MCNC. Person County Proprietary Fiber Network As previously discussed, the County undertook a project several years ago to construct a proprietary fiber network. That network is in operation today. Piedmont Electrical Membership Corporation Fiber Network. (PEMC) Piedmont has constructed a significant fiber network to support electric company operations. PEMC has consistently expressed no interest in providing direct internet services to their member owners. However, they have stated their interest in supporting expansion of broadband in the counties they serve and view the availability of their network as an asset to such efforts by other providers. FCC Based Data Regarding Broadband Availability As previously discussed, broadband providers must submit data to the FCC twice each year on their broadband deployments. Form 477 is the FCC nomenclature which establishes the format of the data submitted. This FCC data is only granular to the census block level; meaning if as few as one location within a block is served by any provider, the whole block is reported as being served. 169 Person County Broadband Study – Executive Summary 9 | Page Outside Plant Inventory A vital part of the project which supports broadband availability gap analysis is the Outside Plant (OSP) inventory work which consists of several integrated steps. Initial Planning In planning the OSP work, ECC reviewed its previous Person County study. The ECC team accessed prior notes, the GIS database, and other data from the previous study to build the baseline for the current study. ECC further requested current GIS information from the Person County GIS team which was then integrated into the baseline database to expand the dataset and enrich the current map views. ECC further acquired data from third party sources. Some of these are proprietary database sources which provide verified GIS data; others are public sources including the FCC, and the NC State BIO group. The result of this work is the creation of the “map book” and drive plan. This is an electronic record utilized by the OSP team in the County. The “map book” is not only electronic, but it is also reduced to paper and placed in a three ring binder for use during the outside work. Outside Plant Inventory This map was provided to the County for review and acceptance prior to any OSP work. Once approved, the OSP team began the fieldwork. The team validated existing fiber and documented new fiber. They further looked for intersections where new fiber was spliced into existing cabling – the new fiber routes were then followed and documented. With incorporated areas having cable coverage, those areas such as Roxboro, were excluded from the OSP work for reasons of time and expense. End User Surveys In considering areas within Person County service gaps, it is important to first analyze households and non-residential entities. Feedback from County residents is a critical componet in the evaluation of unserved and underserved locations. Assessment Three separate surveys have been conducted within the county to garner input from residents. The County conducted a proprietary survey; the State of North Carolina Broadband Infrastructure Office maintains an ongoing assessment, and RiverStreet Networks also completed a demand assessment. Existing Services Maps in the full report provide additional detail about the availability of lowband DSL and high band coaxial based Internet access in Person County. 170 Person County Broadband Study – Executive Summary 10 | Page Summary of Options The study has confirmed there are areas within the County without access to acceptable broadband services or the infrastructure to support the delivery of such services. Like other communities, the County has the option to request providers implement their own programs via RDOF, NTIA, Reconnect, or other means. Due to certain performance components of these programs, the programs will not provide terrestrial coverage of all of the unserved areas and some buildouts may require a six-year wait or longer. Assumptions ECC is making with respect to potential solutions are that the County does not want to be a service provider and deliver broadband service to any premises. Person County could play a supporting role by considering opportunities to incentivize providers to expand services to the unserved areas of the County. The County has held constructive conversations with existing and alternative providers as a first step in reviewing such opportunities. In taking a leadership role, the County has several options in which to accomplish its goals of 100% broadband availability. We believe and recommend that any options considered by the County should include partnerships between the County and service providers working together. Understanding basic concepts relating to networks, as outlined in the full report, is helpful when considering potential options. In any of the options presented below the County should consider the use of Non-Provider infrastructure installed in the County as an incentive for investment; in other words, utilize the existing asset owned by the County. Additionally, the County should require a minimum 100 Mbps x 100 Mbps service be installed to an end user. Option 1 The County can potentially self-fund the build-out of fiber or fixed wireless infrastructure needed to provide unserved end users with broadband access. The County would need to partner with a reliable established broadband provider to operate the network and manage the customer experience. This option would have a significant level of expense and could represent a direct burden to the taxpayers. It does, however, allow for a shared revenue relationship which would allow the County to recover some of the construction and operating costs. Several communities across the U.S., mostly cities and some villages, are implementing this model. It is widely known as Municipal Broadband and examples in North Carolina include the cities of Salisbury and Wilson. ECC does not recommend this as an option for Person County. 171 Person County Broadband Study – Executive Summary 11 | Page Option 2 The County can consider releasing an RFP or enter into a direct negotiation with service providers to create partnerships with broadband service providers. These partnerships would serve to solicit grant funds to pay for infrastructure needed to expand broadband to unserved areas. The next round of the North Carolina GREAT Grant funds may be insufficient to construct enough new network to completely close the broadband gap in the County; but could provide a significant jump start for service providers. Option 3 The County could consider the use of American Rescue Plan (ARP) or newly approved Infrastructure funds to incentivize a service provider to advance buildouts and services. As described in Option 2 above, it is indeterminate at this time if the amount of funds available is sufficient to build new network to all unserved areas of the County. Use of Non Provider infrastructure Within Person County are fiber assets owned by Person County, PEMC and MCNC. Each of these fiber assets offer the County and its potential partners opportunities to reduce the costs and the time associated with building out middle mile fiber. Each of these fiber assets can potentially be utilized by a viable provider willing to use the fiber and build from the fiber to extend service into unserved areas. Access to nonprovider fiber enables providers to focus the bulk of their costs on building last mile solutions. From a financial standpoint, the use of fiber owned by Person County, PEMC or MCNC would provide an financial advantage in justifying investment into the County by providers. If considering expansion of existing fiber assets, the County can further consider how the fiber could benefit anchor institutions such as municpal government, education, healthcare, etc. Use of County fiber infrastructure could qualify the County to create an Open Access fiber model which could provide cost savings and shared operations expense to the County in support of the fiber network. Conclusion In this study, ECC has identified areas within the County that continue to be unserved and underserved (gaps). We have provided, at a summary level, options to assist in closing these gaps such as building out needed infrastructure and providing service and releasing RFP’s, seeking partnerships with providers to install the needed infrastructure and services. The County and community at large have resources that may be brought to bear. Such resources include access to installed County owned fiber, Rights of Way, and vertical structures such as communications and water towers. As discussed in the full report, several options for funding may be available to the County such as state grants, newly approved Infrastructure funds, and County general funds. 172 Person County Broadband Study – Executive Summary 12 | Page Expansion from the current County fiber network could offer new and competitive solutions to anchor institutions within the County such as healthcare, education, government and businesses. Attracting these anchor tenants for the County’s fiber network provides ongoing funding to help support the fiber. ECC believes the next steps are to meet with the County team to discuss in detail the options available and help select the appropiate path forward. 173 Person County Broadband Study – Executive Summary 13 | Page GLOSSARY BACKBONE. Backbone, in the context of networking, refers to the highest speed and widest bandwidth point of a communications circuit or path. In most cases, all information central to the users is connected to the backbone (e.g., shared databases or servers). BANDWIDTH. Bandwidth is the amount of data that can be carried by a circuit between two points of a network. Bandwidth is typically measured in Hertz (cycles per second), bits per second or kilobits per second (shortened to Bps or Kbps). The top speed of today’s modems is 56,000Bps or 56Kbps. The wire connecting a private home to the telephone company carries up to 128,000Bps while one strand of fiber optics can carry 20,000,000,000 (20 Gigabits). A 20Gbps fiber optic strand can interconnect 357,000 telephone calls. 8 bits equal one byte of data – a byte is generally the same as one character – for example the letter “a.” BROADBAND. Broadband is a descriptive term for evolving digital technologies that provide consumers a signal switched facility offering integrated access to voice, high-speed data service, video-demand services, and interactive delivery services. CATV (Cable Television System). A broadband communications system capable of delivering multiple channels of programming from a set of centralized satellite and off-air antennae, generally by coaxial cable, to a community. Many cable-television designs integrate fiber-optic and microwave links. A service through which subscribers pay to have local television stations and additional programs brought into their homes from an antenna via a coaxial cable. CENTRAL OFFICE (CO). A CO is a major equipment center designed to serve the communications traffic of a specific geographic area. CO coordinates are used in mileage calculations for local and interexchange service rates. A Central Office usually has less than 100,000 telephone lines within its wire boundary. COs are usually owned and operated by LECs. CLEC (Competitive Local Exchange Carrier). A CLEC is a telephone company that competes with the incumbent telephone company. The formation of these organizations is a direct result of the Telecommunications Act of 1996. COAXIAL CABLE. A type of cable used for broadband data and cable systems. Also known as “coax.” Coaxial cable is composed of an insulated central conducting wire wrapped in another cylindrical conducting wire. It is usually wrapped in another layer and an outer protective layer and has the capacity to carry great quantities of information. 174 Person County Broadband Study – Executive Summary 14 | Page DARK FIBER. Dark Fiber is fiber optic cable, typically between end user locations, that the end user owns, lights, and operates. DSL (Digital Subscriber Line). DSL is technology that allows for the simultaneous transmission of voice and Internet data over a single telephone line. Central Offices that have DSL technology can support DSL services to customers within approximately 18,000 feet of the Central Office. DSL is delivered either asymmetrically (ADSL) or symmetrically (SDSL). ADSL lines have download transmission rates higher than upload rates and are typical for residential or business users that receive much more Internet content than they send. SDSL are for businesses that generate and receive large amounts of Internet data. DOWNLOAD SPEED. The rate at which data is transferred from the Internet to the user’s computer is termed download speed. This speed is typically stated in Megabits (1,000,000 bits) per second or Gigabits (1,000 Megabits) per second. FIBER OPTICS. The technology of guiding and projecting light for use as a communications medium. Hair- thin glass fibers that allow light beams to be bent and reflected with low levels of loss and interference are known as “glass optical wave guides” or simply “optical fibers.” This cable comes in two types, single mode and multimode, each with its own unique place in communications. Single mode FO cable is typically used where long distances and very high speeds are required, while multimode is used for intra-building communications and places where lower bandwidths are required. FIBER-OPTIC CABLE. A cable containing one or more optical fibers. INCUMBENT LOCAL EXCHANGE CARRIER (ILEC). An ILEC is the local telephone company that provides service to business, organizations, and residences within the LATA. The ILEC is responsible for the development, maintenance, and support of cabling infrastructure necessary to provide telecommunications services within the LATA. INTERNET. A widely used public computer network, initially developed by the U.S. military that links smaller computer networks and allows users on different electronic-mail systems to communicate with one another on a global scale. INTERNET PROTOCOL (IP). In TCP/IP, a connection Internet layer protocol that provides a best-efforts datagram delivery service. Note the functional layer (TCP/IP) corresponds to the OSI model network layer. The Internet layer provides routing and relaying functions that are used when data must be passed from a host to some other network in the Internet. It operates in the source and destination hosts and in all the routers along the path between the hosts. 175 Person County Broadband Study – Executive Summary 15 | Page ISP (Internet Service Provider). A company that provides access to the Internet to individuals or companies. Some ISPs lease connections from Internet backbone providers. LANDLINE. Traditional wired phone service. LAST-MILE. Last Mile is used to describe the final connection to a building, as differentiated from the high capacity circuits extending across a city or County. The connection from the cable television trunk cable to your house is considered a “last-mile” connection. NETWORK. Any connection of two or more computers that enables them to communicate. Networks may include transmission devices, servers, cables, routers, and satellites. The phone network is the total infrastructure for transmitting phone messages. RF (Radio Frequency). RF refers to the electromagnetic waves operating between 10KHz and 3MHz propagated without guide (wire or cable) in free space. RIGHT-OF-WAY. Right of Way (ROW) refers to a designated space alongside a street or other access (such as a railroad line). An entity wishing to install fiber optic cable between various sites/locations must first obtain the rights to a path along those routes. As the cable may be installed underground or on poles, right-of-way access may be granted by a city, a private landowner, or the owner of poles such a cable company, a telephone company or power company. Cities typically require written permits— usually for a fee. SERVICE PROVIDER. A telecommunications provider that owns circuit switching equipment. UPLOAD SPEED. The rate at which data is transferred from the user’s computer to the Internet is termed upload speed. This speed is typically stated in Megabits (1,000,000 bits) per second or Gigabits (1,000 Megabits) per second. WAN (Wide Area Network. WAN is used to extend LAN connectivity beyond a city or County, usually through common carrier facilities. WIRELESS. Wireless describes a means of sending signals (voice, video or data) “over the air” rather than using cables. To date, wireless bandwidth rates (capacities) are significantly lower than wire rates. There are significant new developments in wireless, many of which will come to market in 2014 and beyond. 176 177 178 179