Loading...
06-02-2025 Meeting Minutes BOCJune 2, 2025 1 PERSON COUNTY BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS June 2, 2025 MEMBERS PRESENT OTHERS PRESENT Kyle Puryear Katherine M. Cathey, County Manager Jason Thomas Michele Solomon, Clerk to the Board Sherry Wilborn T.C. Morphis, Jr., County Attorney Antoinetta Royster The Board of Commissioners for the County of Person, North Carolina, met in Regular session on Monday, June 2, 2025 at 6:00 p.m. in the Person County Office Building Auditorium located at 304 S. Morgan Street, Roxboro, NC. Chairman Puryear called the meeting to order and recognized a quorum was present. Vice-Chairman Thomas offered an invocation, and Commissioner Wilborn led the group in the Pledge of Allegiance. County Manager Katherine Cathey stated that Person County is saddened by the recent death of a child. She stated that life is a precious gift. She stated that family, friends, and other individuals who were touched by this young life, including County staff and the community as a whole, grieve this loss. She stated that each and every day, at all hours of the day, County staff seeks to assist and protect the vulnerable, children, adults, the blind, the disabled, and the sick. She stated that dedicated, caring professional employees in Child Protective Services and throughout county government are committed to ensuring Person County is a safe and thriving community. She stated that Person County prioritizes public safety and personal well-being and is committed to maintaining a safe and respectful community and workplace. She stated that county government is accountable to the community and values transparency. She stated that county government is bound by the need to protect confidentiality in many areas of our work. She stated that over the past week, County leadership has received emails demanding accountability and staff has been targeted with phone calls, social media posts, and intrusions in restricted areas of the workplace, as well as on private property. She stated that in response, Person County implores all to act with integrity and respect, and to ensure public safety and personal well-being. As public servants, we will continue to work to protect the vulnerable, ensure a safe community and workplace, share information as appropriate, take ownership of our responsibilities, and be accountable to the community. She stated that County staff will continue to provide effective services, and will accept responsibility and take action if any problems are identified in the ongoing investigation and review of this situation by the NC Department of Health and Human Services. She stated that this is a difficult situation for all involved, and it will take time to gain a deeper understanding of what has occurred. Chairman Puryear stated that he echoed Cathey, and the County wishes to express sympathy to the family. June 2, 2025 2 DISCUSSION/ADJUSTMENT/APPROVAL OF AGENDA: A motion was made by Commissioner Royster and carried 4-0 to approve the agenda. PUBLIC HEARING: REZONING/MAP AMENDMENT APPLICATION RZ-02-24 FOR RHETSON COMPANIES TO REZONE A NEWLY CREATED ±3 ACRE SUBJECT PROPERTY FROM GENERAL INDUSTRIAL (GI) TO HIGHWAY COMMERCIAL (B1) ZONING DESIGNATION A motion was made by Commissioner Wilborn and carried 4-0 to open the duly advertised public hearing for Rezoning/Map Amendment Application RZ-02-24 for Rhetson Companies to rezone a newly created ±3-acre Subject Property from a G-I (General Industrial) to B-1 (Highway Commercial) zoning designation. Interim Planning Director Margaret Hauth presented the following: June 2, 2025 3 June 2, 2025 4 June 2, 2025 5 June 2, 2025 6 Chairman Puryear had questions related to the Planning Board vote. He stated that two members of the Planning Board voted in opposition, saying that the application was incomplete. Hauth stated that with staff turnover in the Planning Department, there was poor communication going on. She stated that the application was complete and that the applicant provided all information timely for the Planning Board meeting. She stated all information is properly before this Board tonight for consideration, as it was also properly before the Planning Board last month. Commissioner Wilborn asked Hauth if she would classify this as downzoning. Hauth stated no she would not classify this as downzoning, based on the Table of Permitted Uses, the list for General Industrial is small, and the list for B-1 is longer and there is more flexibility. Greg Stewart, the applicant, with Rhetson Companies, presented the following: June 2, 2025 7 June 2, 2025 8 June 2, 2025 9 June 2, 2025 10 The following individuals appeared before the Board to speak in favor of Rezoning/Map Amendment Application RZ-02-24 for Rhetson Companies to rezone a newly created ±3-acre Subject Property from a G-I (General Industrial) to B-1 (Highway Commercial) zoning designation. David Newell, owner of said property, stated that he bought this property in the mid 80’s with the intention of building some warehouses for Collins and Aikman, which he is glad fell through as the land remains vacant. Carol Truby of 440 Moss Creek Drive, Roxboro stated that after attending the Civics Academy, she has a lot more faith and confidence in our county process when it comes to rezoning and approving different types of businesses that want to build and come into our county and what they have to go through in order to get approved. Riana Smith, attorney for applicant, Rhetson Companies, stated that she wanted to reiterate what was presented and that it is consistent with the County’s land use plan. A motion was made by Commissioner Wilborn and carried 4-0 to close the duly advertised public hearing for Rezoning/Map Amendment Application RZ-02-24 for Rhetson Companies to rezone a newly created ±3-acre Subject Property from a G-I (General Industrial) to B-1 (Highway Commercial) zoning designation. A motion was made by Commissioner Wilborn and carried 4-0 to approve an ordinance amending the Official Zoning Map of PersonCounty to rezone the ±3- acre Subject Property on Boston Road from a G-I (General Industrial) to B-1 (Highway Commercial) zoning designation as requested by Rhetson Companies, and find it is consistent with the adopted Person County & City of Roxboro Joint Comprehensive Land Use Plan guiding principle 2.1: Designate Sufficient Developable Land and Sites to Support Economic Growth. PUBLIC HEARING: FY2025-2026 BUDGET A motion was made by Commissioner Royster and carried 4-0 to open the duly advertised public hearing for comments relating to the County Manager’s FY 2025-2026 Recommended Budget. There were no individuals appearing before the Board to speak in favor of the County Manager’s FY 2025-2026 Recommended Budget. June 2, 2025 11 The following individual appeared before the Board to speak in opposition of the County Manager’s FY 2025-2026 Recommended Budget. Carol Truby of 440 Moss Creek Drive, Roxboro stated that she wanted to express her opinion on raising taxes and the budget. She stated that if she could see improvements to her or her family life and the fellow residents of the County, then she would be fine with paying more to benefit everyone’s quality of life, specifically through water recreation. She stated that a splashpad would be great and a swimming pool would benefit a lot of people. A motion was made by Commissioner Wilborn and carried 4-0 to close the public hearing for comments relating to the County Manager’s FY 2025-2026 Recommended Budget. INFORMAL COMMENTS: The following individuals appeared before the Board to make informal comments: Kathy Lawrence of 1034 Terry Road, Hurdle Mills stated that she is the chair of the Person County Republican Party. She expressed thanks to the Board for reaching out to seek the recommendation for the Commissioner seat vacancy. She stated that they were given limited time to develop, vet, process, and vote on appropriate candidates for the vacant seat. She stated that despite the time constraints, they had an excellent response from those wanting to be considered. She stated that the Person County Republican Party submitted three viable candidates for consideration, Liz Bradsher, John Byrd, and Jessica Leezer. She stated that each candidate has unique and valuable insights that would help the Person County Board of Commissioners function as an efficient, effective, and transparent manner. She stated that if the Board chooses not to go with the Person County Republican Party’s recommendation, that they articulate why they did not choose from the recommended list. April Short of 362 Gates Run, Timberlake stated that a child passed away in DSS custody and that it was not handled correctly. She stated that the mother was informed of her child’s passing by a phone call, which is heartbreaking and unacceptable. She stated that no parent should receive the devasting news of their child’s death through a cold and impersonal call, and that it is inhumane. She stated, at minimum, a home visit should have been conducted by a trained professional, ideally accompanied by a grief counselor, who could have provided immediate emotional support. She stated that the mother needed someone to show up in person with care and compassion. She stated that this is not just a matter of policy, it is a matter of care and dignity. June 2, 2025 12 Short stated that this tragic incident reveals a deeper systematic issue within DSS here in Person County, which appears to lack accountability and failure in communication protocols, as well as a disregard for the emotional well-being of families. She stated that these are not small oversights, they are critical failings that further traumatized already vulnerable people. She stated that in that moment of unthinkable grief, the mother needed presence, and support, someone to show up in person to offer care and compassion. She stated that DSS lacks empathy and professionalism. She stated that if someone lacks basic customer service skills, not friendly, not patient or approachable, then they have no business being in a public-facing role, especially at DSS. She stated that the job requires more than paperwork and policies, it requires a heart and compassion. She stated that there needs to be a review of DSS policies and procedures, and that staff needs to be trained. She urged the Bord to conduct a full review of the department’s internal practices, training standards, and hiring policies Shelia Crisp stated that she is the great-grandmother of the deceased child. She stated that her heart is breaking for her family. She stated that she is trying to be strong for her grand-daughter and for the children. She stated that the pain is unbearable. She stated that the Department of Social Services does not see the damage they have done, as they have moved on to the next file, the next case, the next name. She stated that the family cannot move on. She stated that her other grandchild needs to come home. She stated that she has been fully approved by Granville County to care for her. She stated that she has opened her heart and her home, yet Person County continues to block her from getting her grandchild. She stated that she does not understand, and that no one has explained it to her. She stated that her family is hurting, and this system is keeping them apart from her. She stated that she is just a little girl, that is scared, confused, and grieving the loss of her baby brother. She stated that what her grandchild needs is stability, love, and to be surrounded by family. She stated that the mother of the child needs to be able to hold her. She stated that she is calling on the Commissioners to do what is right to oversee DSS and return her grandchild to her family. Briauna Morgan stated that most people will never have to feel this kind of pain, but asked people to imagine being at work, when your phone rings and on the other end someone tells you that your baby, your sweet, innocent one-year old son is gone. She stated no goodbyes, no explanation, just gone, and that you would never be able to see him again. She stated that her son, Kemari Morgan died while in the custody of Person County. She stated that she has no answers, and does not know how or why this happened. She stated that the people who were supposed to protect him, failed him. She stated that she has to live every day worrying about her daughter, who is two-years old, and was in the same home when her brother died. She stated that she does not know where she is, and has not been able to speak with the people who have her. She stated that her grandmother could provide a safe and stable placement. She stated that this is not just about justice, it is about a system that tore her family apart in their darkest moments. June 2, 2025 13 Morgan stated enough is enough, that she is demanding her daughter come home. She stated that she knows the Commissioners in this county have the power to oversee DSS, as they govern them and are responsible for their decisions. She asked them to do what is right and bring her daughter home, so her family can grieve together, heal together, and be able to survive. Pamela Lester stated that she is standing here because she is a woman of God, that she trusts that He is going to make the right decision, and give us the right vison, and the way that we should go. She stated that they did not come here to fight, they came in a peaceful manner to let the Board know that they are going to stand and not going to sit down on this. She stated that they will keep going as high as they need to go, and will not stop until the babies come home, and they get answers. She stated that it makes no sense. She asked why were the children taken from the mother, just because she made a mistake, even though the children were not in her presence at the time of the mistake. She stated that no one wants to say anything. She stated that it is not time to be quiet. She stated it is time to let everyone know what happened, as everybody had something to say when they said she was an unfit mother, and could not have her kids. She stated that the system is not working, and they put children in homes with no license, because the judge says it is okay. She stated that the family has support and will be cared for. She stated that they are going to continue to fight, but not with guns or weapons, but with the Lord and each other, and go as high as they need to go. She stated that they are going to stand as a family, and the County needs to give her children back to her tonight. Rob Yates of 2419 Radrick Lane, Charlotte expressed thanks to the Board for their time. He stated that he is the Communications Director for the Libertarian Party of NC. He stated that he has ran for office a few times and has had the opportunity to meet a number of elected officials. He stated that he reflects on the words of the great Thomas Sowell who talked about the folly of bureaucrats being the distinction between intent and outcome, and in this case, he has no reason to question anybody’s intent. He stated that he is sure they all want the best for everyone in this county, but the outcome is the greatest tragedy imaginable. He stated that as a parent, he listened to Ms. Morgan speak, and he cannot even contemplate the crushing weight of the sorrow she must be feeling. He stated the outcome was the death of a child. He stated that this is an utter failure of the system in every single way, the worst possible outcome, and that there is nothing worse that could have happened had that child stayed with his mom. He stated that the Board has the power and ability to do what is right. Thomas Hill of 10896 Pioneer Mill Road, Concord stated that he is a peaceful man with PTSD, and that he would try to stay calm. He stated that we needed to cut to the chase and get down and cut the “bs” right now. He asked if the Sheriff, or the highest law enforcement officer was in the room. June 2, 2025 14 Hill stated that the decent thing to do is come up to this woman and offer her a ride to go pick up her child, allowing her to hold her baby and grieve, less than that is not acceptable. He stated that the only thing he could do was to appeal to the Sheriff’s/Law Enforcement Officer’s conscience. He pleaded for the mother to get her child back. He stated that the Board does not realize the grace he is showing them tonight, and he knows that they want to do what is right. He stated that sometimes doing the right thing is the hardest thing to do in the world. He stated that this is not going to stand and that they will make the Board famous. He stated that this is not his first rodeo, that he knows how to get things done. He stated that he would not name the organization, but since they are good Republicans, give Governor Brian Kemp in Georgia a call and see how they have been dealing with him. He stated that this is a wake-up call for everybody. He stated that he is scared of none of them. Sharrocka Pettiford of 833 Berwyn Avenue, Durham expressed thanks to the Board for allowing her to speak and recognizing stolen children’s month. She stated that she wanted to make sure that it is painfully clear for many families in our community, especially black families, this is not a symbolic observance, it is a live reality, a daily trauma. She stated that it is a system that continues to take children away from loving parents under the weight of systematic bias and broken policies. She stated that we are here today not just for injustice but to demand change starting with bring this child home. She stated that this child should be home with her mother. She stated that the mother has done everything asked of her, has shown perseverance and strife in the face of a system that too often punishes black motherhood. She stated that instead of supporting it, the child welfare system is not protecting children, it is disappearing them. She stated that black mothers are bearing the heaviest burden. She stated that this is not about individual failures, it is about institutional decision. She stated that the Board has the power, responsibility, and authority to bring her home. She stated that this child does not need to spend another day without her mother. She stated that they will continue to raise their voices, not just for her, but for every child and mother that this system has failed. Amanda Wallace of Durham stated that she is the founder of Operation Stop CPS, which is based in Durham. She stated that Operation Stop CPS brings issues to light, so that they cannot be swept under the rug. She stated that what has been done to this family is unacceptable and inhumane. She stated that Board is the governing board, she watched the meeting on YouTube when they decided to take control over the Department of Social Services and do away with the Social Services Board. She asked the Board, what are they going to do tonight. She stated that this is not just one family’s story; over 200,000 children are separated from their families each year, rights terminated, families disappeared. She stated that this a problem. She mentioned the family policing system. She stated that she is here to educate the Board as well as the community about what the family policing system is. She stated that Carlton Paylor is not protecting children, that he is separating families, and disappearing them in Person County. June 2, 2025 15 Wallace stated that she has received pictures of babies with burns in Person County custody, and families are coming forward telling her what is going on. She stated that this child should be at home tonight. She asked the Board what are they doing in their capacity to bring her home. She stated that if they could not answer, publicly, have a conversation with the mother before leaving tonight. DISCUSSION/ADJUSTMENT/APPROVAL OF CONSENT AGENDA: A motion was made by Commissioner Wilborn and carried 4-0 to approve the Consent Agenda with the following items: A. May 19, 2025 Minutes B. Budget Amendment #22 NEW BUSINESS: APPOINTMENT OF NEW COMMISSIONER County Attorney T.C. Morphis, Jr. expressed thanks to Kathy Lawrence, who spoke earlier, for providing the recommended names from the Person County Republican Party for the vacant Board of Commissioners seat. He stated the names provided were, Liz Bradsher, John Byrd and Jessica Leezer. He stated that the Board had been provided that information last Monday. He stated that he appreciated the party meeting the deadline, as we are in the midst of budget season, and making important decisions for FY 2025-2026. He asked the Board if there was additional discussion or any additional names to be added for recommendation. Commissioner Wilborn stated that what the Board is about to do tonight is not easy, and not an ideal situation that was thrust upon them. She stated that she is very big on democracy. She stated that in the last meeting, she asked that the Board adopt a variation of the County’s Organizational Chart that models the School of Government, where the voters are at the top. She stated and here we are in another instance of why it is important and to recognize that. She stated that the County has found themselves in a situation where a person that the voters chose is not able to fulfill the duties of the office. She stated that it is not efficient to hold an entire election to fill that one seat, and it is not the way the General Statutes have laid out so that the position can be filled. She stated that it falls on the Board, the remaining four, that the voters have chosen to make that appointment. She stated that she thinks that is the most appropriate plan. She stated the provision in the statute allows the local party to put up a nomination, and she appreciates them for doing that. She mentioned Derrick Sims, as a possible nomination, and in speaking with the Chairman, it was the consensus of the Board to not nominate anyone who ran in the most recent election and was not elected. June 2, 2025 16 Wilborn stated after she realized that the Board was going to have to fill the seat, it was important to her that it be someone who has gone through an election cycle as a candidate, who understands how long that process is, how difficult it is on a person and their family, how expensive it is, and who has been willing to stick their neck out to devote the time to serve. She stated that she had three people to speak to her about their willingness or desire to fill the seat. She stated that of those three people, only one of them was not in the most recent election and not elected. She stated that this person meets her personal criteria of having gone through an election cycle as a candidate. She stated that she has served alongside this person for the last twelve years, and while they have had their differences, and do not agree on every issue, she believes he loves Person County and has its best interest at heart, which has been demonstrated by his service over the years on various boards and civic organizations. She stated that she can attest that he has been engaged and has paid attention to the needs of Person County, and the desire to see it prosper. She stated that she wishes to nominate Donald Long to fill the vacant seat on the Person County Board of Commissioners. Chairman Puryear advised the Board of Wilborn’s motion and asked for comments from the other Board members. Commissioner Royster advised that she has worked with Long for several years, and has known him for many years. She stated while they have not always seen eye to eye on certain issues, she has witnessed firsthand Long’s leadership and love for Person County. She stated that she supports the nomination. Vice-Chairman Thomas stated that he has battled with this for a while because he kind of was there with Sims, as he has seen how hard he has worked for the County and he felt like Sims had put his whole self into the seat and wanted what was best for the County. He stated that he also believes the same way about Long. He stated that he has no doubt that Long is going to give 120% to the seat, and that he would be respectful and do the job that he knows how to do. He stated that he is in favor of the motion. Puryear asked Long to approach the Board and asked if he had any comments he would like to express to the Board. Long stated that he loved Person County and would like to continue to serve Person County in any way that he could. Puryear stated that he and Long have a history together, some good, and some not so good. He stated as far as the negative history, that it is ancient and in the past, and hopes Long feels the same. Long stated that he feels the same. A motion was made by Commissioner Wilborn and carried 4-0 to appoint Donald Long to fill the Republican vacancy on the Board of Commissioners to December 7, 2026. Chairman Puryear congratulated Long as the new Commissioner designee and advised that he would be sworn in Friday morning at 9:00 a.m. during the Budget Work Session. Long stated that he is humbled by the Board’s support. June 2, 2025 17 OPTIONS FOR NEXT STEPS RELATED TO THE UNIFIED DEVELOPMENT ORDINANCE (UDO) Interim Planning Director Margaret Hauth stated that it is her understanding from the last meeting that the Board had questions and expressed an interest in an update to the UDO. She stated that she has been reviewing the various planning ordinances since her arrival in February. She stated that she has found a number of conflicts, cross reference errors, and state law reference errors. She stated that adoption of the Unified Development Ordinance would have addressed these issues. She stated that since that action doesn’t seem to be immediately forthcoming, she would like to pursue some of this clean-up to keep the county and staff on solid legal footing until the UDO can be revisited. She stated that this is scheduled for Planning Board discussion for June 12. CHAIRMAN’S REPORT Chairman Puryear asked County Manager Katherine Cathey if there was a request to set up a meeting or tele-conference with the victim’s mother. Cathey stated that she spoke to Amanda Wallace today, and that she suggested a meeting with Briauna Morgan, who is here tonight. She stated that she advised Wallace that she would be glad to set up a meeting with Morgan to include DSS Director Carlton Paylor and Assistant County Manager Brian Hart. Puryear stated he would like to expediate that meeting and he would like to attend as well as another Commissioner. COMMISSIONER REPORTS/COMMENTS Vice-Chairman Thomas expressed thanks to all for coming out tonight and giving their heart to them. He stated that the Board will do everything they can that is within their limits. He stated that they are praying for the family. He stated that Person County lost a great giant of a man, Rob Hall, and asked all to remember his family in prayers as they lay him to rest this week. Commissioner Royster stated that she empathizes with the family of baby Kemari. She stated that she does want to make clear the frustration; she has seen the tears and seen, firsthand, children removed from homes. She stated that she was a former social worker and it is work that she has done for over 16 years. She stated that the previous Board voted to oversee DSS. She stated that when children are removed a judge makes that decision and they cannot overrule a judge’s decision. She encouraged the family to ask questions; they have that right. She stated that she commends the family’s support system. June 2, 2025 18 Commissioner Wilborn thanked Royster for her comments, as the member of the Board with the most training, education, and experience on the subject. She stated that it is a very difficult subject. She stated that it is a judicial decision. She stated that the Board of E&R has continued to meet weekly and will do so for the remainder of the month. She stated that on Friday of last week, North American had an open house and hiring event, as they are under new ownership, and have new contracts, and desperately need 100 people to start work. A motion was made by Vice-Chairman Thomas and carried 4-0 to enter into Closed Session at 7:19 p.m. CLOSED SESSION A motion to enter into Closed Session per General Statute 143-318.11(a)(3) for the purpose to consult with the county attorney in order to preserve the attorney-client privilege and General Statute 143-318(a)(1) to prevent the disclosure of information that is privileged or confidential pursuant to the law of this State or of the United States, or not considered a public record within the meaning of Chapter 132 of the General Statutes with the following individuals permitted to attend: County Manager Katherine Cathey, Clerk to the Board Michele Solomon, Assistant County Manager/Consolidated Human Services Director Brian Hart, Social Services Director Carlton Paylor and County Attorney T.C. Morphis, Jr. Chairman Puryear called the closed session to order at 7:24 p.m. A motion was made by Commissioner Wilborn and carried 4-0 to return to open session at 8:15 p.m. RECESS: A motion was made by Commissioner Wilborn and carried 4-0 to recess the meeting at 8:17 p.m. until Friday, June 6, 2025 at 9:00 a.m.in the Commissioners’ Boardroom 215 in the Person County Office Building located at 304 S. Morgan Street, Roxboro, NC. ____________________________ ______________________________ Michele Solomon Kyle Puryear Clerk to the Board Chairman